Persian Dominance in Commerce and Islamization on the Malay-Indonesian Archipelago: An Analysis of Historic Loanwords

Written by Afsheen Sharifzadeh, a graduate of Tufts University focusing on Iran and the Caucasus. The present article delves into historic commercial and religious contacts between West Asia and the Malay-Indonesian Archipelago from the 9th to the 18th centuries AD. While one might anticipate a significant presence of Arabic loanwords in Malay related to maritime activities and commerce, the analysis surprisingly reveals that such loans predominantly originate from Persian rather than Arabic, pointing to a misattribution of influence. The author argues that a Persian-speaking merchant network played a central role in the Indian Ocean and South China Sea, shedding light on historical linguistic dynamics and questioning the presumed dominance of Arabic in certain domains.

(1) Papan Tinggi cemetery complex at Barus, on the west coast of Sumatra, Indonesia (2) The gravestone of one Shaykh Maḥmūd (1426 CE). The headstone is inscribed with a couplet from the Shāhnāmah (Book of Kings) of Ferdowsī (d. c. 1020 CE) addressing the subject of mortality and the impermanence of “worldly life”: جهان یادگارست و ما رفتنى/ ز مرد نماند به جز مردمى “The world is a perpetual remembrance and we all leave it in the end; people will leave nothing behind but their good deeds.”

Background
In examining commercial contacts between West Asia and the Malay-Indonesian archipelago between the 9th and 18th centuries AD, the term “Arabian” is often invoked to describe the ethnolinguistic affiliation of the foreign merchants involved in such exchanges across modern English, Malay and Indonesian language sources. We might therefore expect to encounter an array of vernacular Arabic loans in Malay (and in other indigenous Austronesian languages on Sumatra and Java, including Acehnese, Minangkabau, Javanese and Sundanese) pertaining specifically to maritime activities, commerce, and daily social exchanges. However, upon analysis, it becomes evident that loans in those domains almost exclusively originate from Persian rather than Arabic, offering a different narrative. This is in some ways unsurprising, since robust linguistic and genetic evidence has demonstrated that Persians rather than Arabs formed the dominant ‘Muslim’ component in China1, the Thai Kingdom of Ayutthaya2, and the Swahili coast of Africa3, and that use of the term ‘Arab’ is in many cases the result of a broad misattribution which has been replicated for various reasons, discussed below. The matter is further complicated by the historical currency of Persian throughout the Indian subcontinent, where it served as the official language in some regions such as Delhi and Bengal for a period of nearly 600 years and in others, at the very least, as the lingua franca, from the 13th century onwards. It appears, nonetheless, that diligent scrutiny of the available data has hardly been undertaken by numerous authors venturing to forward our understanding of the subject, and hasty reproduction of the same misconceptions surrounding ‘Arab’ involvement has, regrettably, obscured an authentic portal of contact, by now having apparently receded into oblivion among the Malay-Indonesians and Iranians themselves. Observe the following Persian loanwords in Classical Malay for important nautical terms (many now obsolete or archaic), including ‘merchant’, ‘sailor’, ‘captain’, ‘harbor master’, ‘port’, ‘warrant officer’:

Classical MalayPersianEnglish
Anjimanانجمن anjuman “association”An East Indiaman; a large transport or trading vessel belonging to the East India Company
Awarآوار āvārDamage of ship or load
Badباد bādWind
Balabad بالا باد bālā bādHigh wind, land breeze
Bamبام bām “ceiling”Crosspiece (a bar or timber connecting two knightheads or two bitts on a ship)
Bandarبندر bandarPort, harbor
Gazگز gazA Persian unit of length, ranging from 24 to 41 inches
Gusiگشا gušāmizzen sail; gaff mainsail
Jangkarلنگر langarAnchor
Kelasiخلاشى xalāši (from خلاش “rudder”)Sailor
Khojaخواجه ājaMerchant
Nakhodaناخدا nākhodāCaptain, shipmaster
Persanggaفرسنگ farsangA Persian measure of distance, equivalent to about four miles
Saudagarسوداگر sowdāgarMerchant
Serangسرهنگ sarhangThe officer (or warrant officer) in charge of sails, rigging, anchors, cables etc. and all work on deck of a sailing ship
Syabandar شاه بندر
šāh bandar
Harbormaster
Takhta rawan تخت روان
takht ravān
Palanquin, the moving throne

At the time of writing, the only Malay nautical terms of Arabic extraction known to this author are farsakh “an ancient Persian unit of distance, equivalent to about 4 miles” (doublet of persangga; from Persian فرسنگ farsang via Arabic فرسخ farsakh, also reborrowed into Persian as farsakh) and bahar “sea” (from Arabic بحر baḥr), but the route of their transmission is uncertain due to their simultaneous presence in Persian. If the primary participants in maritime trade were indeed predominantly Arab merchants hailing from the Ḥaḍramaut (a southern coastal region of the Arabian Peninsula), with Persian-speakers playing a secondary role in these exchanges, then the near complete absence of Arabic nautical loanwords in Malay poses a significant paradox. Why were nautical terms from a ‘minority’ foreign language selectively borrowed?

On the contrary, the remains of a shipwreck in Phanom Surin, Samut Sakhon province, Thailand dating to before the advent of Islam with an inscription of the presumed shipowner Yazd-bōzēd in Middle Persian, as well as a garnet set in gold finger ring found in Palembang, Sumatra (7th-9th century?) engraved in an elegant Pahlavi script with the Middle Persian word āfrīn, “blessing”, suggests Persians had maintained the maritime routes to China where sizable Zoroastrian, Manichaean, Christian and Jewish Iranian communities are known to have existed for centuries prior to Islam. Further Perso-Arabic, Pahlavi and Judeo-Persian inscriptions belonging to a 9th century Persian-speaking merchant community operating under state privileges on the Malabar Coast of southwest India in the same time frame as the shipwrecked Phanom Surin vessel confirms the wider network in which these objects’ discoveries must be seen. Later in the 15th century, according to the historian Ismail Marcinkowski, “…Persian was the lingua franca in the Indian Ocean trading world and a Persian-speaking merchant community was present in Malacca. The office with the Persian title of Šāhbandar (شاه بندر “harbor master”), known in many of the Indian Ocean trade ports as well as in several parts of the Ottoman Empire, was also established in Malacca.”4 This confirms and advances the existence of a longstanding Persianate commercial network in the Indian Ocean and South China Sea centered around a Persian-speaking merchant oligarchy, which in medieval times included Persian-speaking Gujaratis and Bengalis, as well as Hadhrami Arabs.

This is further corroborated by multiple foreign travelers’ attestations to the highly influential and thriving resident colonies of Persian-speaking merchants in Zaiton (泉州 Quánzhōu) in the 14th century and in Siam’s capital of Ayutthaya in the 16th century. Notably, the descendants of some of the original Persian traders in Ayutthaya (known since the 15th century by a Persian epithet Scierno, from Šahr-e nāv “City of Boats and Canals” among Western mariners and travelers around the rim of the Indian Ocean), members of the aristocratic Thai-Persian Bunnag, Siphen and Singhseni families, continued to be in positions close to the Thai throne into the 20th century. The rich and flavorful massaman curry (แกงมัสมั่น kǣng mát-sà-màn), a corruption of a Persian word mosalmān مسلمان “Muslim”, is attributed to the 17th century Persian community in Ayutthaya through Sheikh Ahmad of Qom (ca. 1543–1631), the patriarch of the Bunnag family.

(1) Tomb of the Persian-born merchant Sheikh Ahmad of Qom (ca. 1543–1631), in Ayutthaya, Thailand. He became a powerful official in the Siamese court, where he was given the title of Châophráya Boworn Râtcháyók (Thai: เจ้าพระยาบวรราชนายก). He was the ancestor of the powerful Thai-Persian Bunnag family (2) Massaman curry paste (มัสมั่น mát-sà-màn, from Persian mosalmān مسلمان “Muslim”), created by the prosperous 17th century Persian community of Ayutthaya, consists of cinnamon, nutmeg, cumin, star anise, clove, cardamom, mace (all brought by traders, including Persians, from the Malay-Indonesian archipelago to Siam) and the decidedly un-Thai flourish of raisins and bay leaves (from Iranian cuisine) combined with ingredients more commonly used in Thai cuisine such as coriander, lemongrass, galangal, white pepper, shrimp paste, shallots, and garlic. This dish, along with others inspired by Persian dishes, is among the recipes in the funeral cookbooks of the Bunnag family5

A distinction should be drawn here, for the argument does not require that all the bearers of these words were Iranians. From the thirteenth century onward Persian was the language of courts and of commerce across the Indian subcontinent, and the merchants of Gujarat and Bengal who sailed east to Malacca carried it as a matter of professional necessity, whatever tongue they spoke at home; the lascar crews of the Indian Ocean, drawn from every shore of it, worked their ships in a vocabulary that was largely Persian, and the words nakhoda and serang belong to that world. It is accordingly probable that many of the loans assembled above reached Malay through Indo-Persian intermediaries rather than from Persian mouths. The claim, properly stated, concerns the language rather than the sailors: the commercial civilization of the Indian Ocean conducted its business in Persian, so that a harbormaster in Malacca held a Persian title, a Gujarati supercargo reckoned in Persian measures, and a Malay chronicler writing of ships and of kings reached for Persian words. The presence of Persians themselves is attested well enough, at Barus and at Ayutthaya; but the deeper fact is that of a Persianate world, in which the language outran the nation that made it, as the nautical Arabic of the Mediterranean once outran the Arabs, and as English outruns England today.

Analysis of Persian loanwords in Malay related to the goods these merchants would have brought illuminates the story further:

Classical MalayPersianEnglish
Almasالماس almāsDiamond
Andamاندام andāmArrangement 
Anggurانگور angūrGrapes, wine (Thai: องุ่น à-ngùn)
Anjir انجير anjirFig
Badamبادام bādāmAlmond
Bajuبازو bāzū “arm”Shirt
Baksisبخشش baxšišWage, reward
Balurبلور bolūrCrystal
Biusبيهوش bi-hūšAnesthetic
Bozahبوزه būzeFermented drink made from wheat or millet
Cadarچادر čādar “tent, veil”Bed cover or tablecloth
Destarدستار dastārHeaddress
Gandumگندم gandomWheat
Gulگل golRose
Kaftanخفتان xaftānA long Persian tunic
Kahrabكهربا kahrobāAmber 
Kasaكاسه kāseBowl
Kelebutكالبد kālbodShoemaker’s last
Kismis كشمش kišmišRaisin 
Kojaكوزه kūzaBottlenecked earthenware
Kurmaخرما xormāDate
Lajakلچک lačakWoven fabric from yarn or silk
Mohorمهر mohrStamp, seal
Percaپارچه pārčaCloth from remainder fabric
Pialaپياله piālaCup, chalice
Picisپشيز pešiz “small”Penny (archaic), of small worth
Pingganپنگان pengān “bowl”Dish, plate
Piringپرنگ parang “copper”Plate
Pirusفيروز firuzTurquoise
Sadirنشادر nošâdorAmmonium chloride
Sakarشكر šakarSugar
Syalشال šālShawl
Tembakauتمباكو tambākuTobacco
Tenggahتنگه tangaA piece of gold or silver
Lazuardi لاجوردى lājevardiLapis lazuli
Zamrudزمرد zomorrodEmerald

On Arabic Loans in Malay-Indonesian
It is important to note that words with Arabic etymologies exist in high quantities in Malay (and by extension, Indonesian), far exceeding the number of ‘pure’ Persian loans. This is unsurprising since Classical Arabic—the mastery of which is required for proper interpretation of the Quran and Hadith—would have been known across generations of Muslim clergy even in the absence of a significant community of Arabs. Accordingly, the majority of Arabic terms in Malay-Indonesian are either demonstrably (1) learned borrowings of more recent literary provenance, based on their semantic domains and unadapted phonology, rather than the result of regular language contact with a vernacular Arabic variety or (2) adopted through the medium of Persian. The number of Malay words borrowed directly from Arabic in the opinion of this author has been, therefore, considerably overestimated. This extensive misclassification has lent false credence to the idea of a historically robust Arab–Malay relationship to the exclusion of Persians, who, according to all available evidence, probably formed the numerically predominant and culturally hegemonic ‘Muslim’ community in Southeast Asia in medieval times. Furthermore, the tombs of multiple venerated Persian shaykhs in Sumatra, such as that of one Shaykh Maḥmūd from Barus, dating to 1426 CE and inscribed, interestingly, with a couplet from the Shāhnāmah (Book of Kings) of Ferdowsī (d. c. 1020 CE), indicate that Persian Muslims served as a vector of Islamization and thus transmission of Arabic to the region.

Towards understanding the words in group (2) above, given the presence of manifestly Persian phonologic and semantic mutations to numerous Arabic terms in Malay, these lexical items must have been adopted through the medium of Persian rather than directly from Arabic. For example, feminine nouns with the final ta marbuta ة are often, but not always, transformed to ta ت in Persian, and this feature is present in numerous Malay words (e.g. Malay selamat “wellbeing” from Arabic سلامة salāma via Persian سلامت salāmat; hakikat “truth” from Arabic حقيقة aqiqa via Persian حقيقت haqiqat). Calques from Persian are also present which have been misattributed to Arabic influence. For example, Indonesian apa khabar? “How are you?” (lit. “what news”?) is in all probability a calque of Persian چه خبر če xabar? If this phrase had been calqued from a vernacular Arabic variety from the Arabian Peninsula, it would have been expected to yield a form like *apa akhbar mu, with the plural noun akhbar and the Malay second person possessive enclitic -mu (cf. a peninsular Arabic vernacular ايش اخبارك ēsh axbārek). Moreover, Arabic-derived terms in Persian that were never actually used in living Arabic must have been borrowed into Malay via Persian. For instance, Malay tamadun “civilization” originates from the Arabic verbal noun تَمَدُّن tamaddun “to become urbanized”, but must have been adopted through Persian تمدن tamaddon “civilization”, since living Arabic instead uses حضارة ḥaḍāra “civilization”, a term unknown in Persian and, by extension, Malay.

The arrival of the British and Dutch East India companies in the 18th century heralded the end of Persianate commerce and the gradual disappearance of Persian-speakers from the Malay-Indonesian Archipelago. The subsequent introduction of steamships by the Europeans instead facilitated Malay-Indonesian contacts with sacred places and study centers on the Arabian Peninsula and in Egypt, wherefrom returning pilgrims began to spread puritanical ideas, particularly Wahhabism. Thus by the 19th century, the Malay-Indonesian world had decidedly turned its gaze toward Arabia rather than Persia, which was increasingly associated with heresy and deviant thought, especially with Shi’ism, Sufism and an abundance of Zoroastrian customs all flourishing on its soil. This, in turn, gave way to leveling of many Persian words in favor of their Arabic equivalents, as Arabic continued to be actively studied and mastered as the holy language of Islam. Words such as aftab “sun”, which were previously known in Malay, were survived only by their Arabic synonyms (Malay syamsu from Arabic شمس šams). In some cases, under prescriptive influences, Persianized Arabic words with meanings unique to Persian were supplanted by their original Arabic meanings. For example, Classical Malay logat which has the Persianized –at ending and historically held the Persian meaning of “word; dictionary” has now shifted towards the original Arabic meaning of “vernacular”, but retains its Persian phonology. In other cases however, such as sejarah “pedigree; history”, the Persian meaning was retained.

MalayPersianArabicEnglish
umatommatumma[Muslim] community
berkatbarekatbarakaBlessing
tamaduntamaddonḥaḍāraCivilization
sejarahšajare “family tree”šajara “tree”Family tree, history
akhlakakhlāq “character, nature”akhlāq “morals, ethics”Character, nature
logatloghat “word”lugha “idiom”1. Word; dictionary (archaic)
2. Vernacular, idiom

Commercial and Cultural Loanwords from Persian
Nevertheless, Persian loanwords with frequent occurrence in informal speech paint scenes of significant social interaction between Persians and the indigenous populations of the Malay Peninsula, Borneo, Sumatra, and Java. This includes both positive instances of intermarriage and occasions of disagreement or conflict. Note multiple words have undergone significant reshaping, in contrast to Arabic loans, indicating their adoption through normal language contact and transformation through high frequency use. More interesting is the conspicuous absence of Arabic loans in the informal register, including colloquialisms and explicit terms (compare Malay bedebah “damned; fuck it!” from Persian بدبخت badbakht; biadab “rude” from Persian بى ادب biadab; haram jadah from حرام‌زاده harāmzādah “bastard”; syabas from شاباش šābāš “well done!”; etc.), which further casts doubt upon the notion that Arabic was ever used for interethnic communication:

Classical MalayPersianEnglish
Acarآچار āčārPickle, marinade
Adatعادت ādatTradition, custom
Badi بدى badi Bad influence (obsolete)
Bahariبهارى bahāri “vernal”Beautiful (obsolete)
Bakhبخش baxšFortunate, happy (archaic)
Bedebah!بدبخت badbakhtDamned, infernal; (offensive, vulgar) fuck it! 
Betahبهتر behtarComfortable; recovered
Biadabبى ادب bi-adabRude, impolite
Bustanبستان bōstān Garden, orchard
Calakچالاک čālākGood, outstanding; talkative 
Derjiدرزى darziTailor
Dayahدايه dāyaFoster mother 
Dewala ديوال divāl “wall”Wall of a city
Dewanaديوانه devānaMadly in love
Geman, Gamangگمان gomān Afraid, frightened
Geramگرم garmIndignant; angry, infuriated
Gustiكشتى kuštiWrestling
Haram jadahحرام‌زاده harāmzādahBastard
Honarهنر honar “craft, ability”Mischief, commotion
Kanduri خندورى khanduriFeast, ceremonial meal
Kawinكابين kābinTo get married; to have sex
Keskulكشكول kaškūlBeggar’s bowl
Kofteكوفته kōfta، from
كوفتن kōftan “to grind”
Various spicy meatball or meatloaf dishes
Nisanنشان nešānTombstone
Panjaپنجه panjeHand
Pasarبازار bāzārMarket
Pesonaافسون afsun “spell, incantation”Enthralling, dazzling
Pirangفرنگ farang “European”Blond; of a golden brown color (Thai: ฝรั่ง fá-ràng “foreigner”)
Sanubariصنوبرى ṣanobari “pine-like; the slender and graceful beloved”Heart, heartstrings
Serbat شربت‎ šarbatA drink prepared from fruits, flower petals
Siumanهوشمند hūšmand “intelligent, wise”Conscious, mentally healthy
Syabasشاباش šābāšBravo, well done!
Tamanچمن čaman “lawn, orchard”Park
Tamasya تماشا tamāšā “look, watch a spectacle”Festival; the act of going out and looking at things

Garnet set in a gold finger ring, engraved in Pahlavi script with the Middle Persian word āfrīn, “blessing”. Reportedly found in Palembang, Sumatra (the location of the historic entrepot of Srivijaya), 7th to 9th century. Private collection, Hong Kong

The Islamized Austronesians incorporated Persianate court styles and military culture into their societies, although most of these terms are today either archaic or have been rendered obsolete:

Classical MalayPersianEnglish
Bahadurبهادر bahādurHero
Cambukچابک čābok “horsewhip”Whip
Dewanديوان dēwānCourt, council
Firmanفرمان farmāncommandment
Getaكت katDais, throne
Jinزين zinSaddle
Johanجهان jahānWorld; hero
Khanjarخنجر khanjarDagger (Thai: กั้นหยั่น gân-yàn)
Kianiكيانى kiāniThrone
Kulahكلاه kulāhA kind of helmet, headgear
Laskarلشكر laškarArmy, soldier
Pahlawanپهلوان pahlavānHero, brave warrior
Siasatسياست siāsatTactic, politic
Syah Alam شاه عالم
šāh-e ‘ālam “King of the world”
Title of the sultan of Selangor
Tajukتاجک tājakCrown 
Takhtaتخت takhtThrone
Tarkasترکش‎ tarkašQuiver
Zirahزره zirihArmor

The Classical Malay literary tradition as well as Islamic scholarship were marked by widespread Persian cultural influences, much like on the nearby Indian subcontinent. The enigmatic Malay Sufi poet, Ḥamza Fanṣuri (of Fanṣur, modern Barus), who flourished under the reigning Sultan ʿAlāʾ al-Din Reʿāyat Šāh (r. 1588-1604), had a thorough knowledge of Arabic and Persian. In some of his works, he quotes from the masters of classical Persian mysticism such as Šabestari, either in Persian, or in Malay translation. Notable representation of the advice genre, or naṣiḥat, also bear clear parallels to classical Persian literature. An exemplary illustration of this link is the Tāj al-Salāṭin composed by Boḵāri al-Jawhari (perhaps a native of Johor in southern Malaya?) during the 17th century. This work, translated into Malay from an unidentified Persian source in the Aceh Sultanate of Sumatra, not only showcases thematic similarities with earlier Persian compositions like Neẓām al-Molk’s Siāsat-nāma, but also incorporates Persian expressions, such as nowruz, to denote the commencement of a new year. Another work is Bustān al-Salāṭin, also composed in Aceh around the mid-17th century, by Nur-al-Din Rāniri, who was born in India and was deeply immersed in the Persian scholarly tradition. The meticulous adherence to Persian models suggests these Malay works as faithful translations. Both compositions explore the theme of the “Just King” as epitomized by Anoshervan, the archetypal ruler of Sasanian Iran.

Thus, while Arabic enjoys special status for all Muslims including Persians, much like Ecclesiastical Latin for Catholics, review of historic loanwords in Malay reveals that the majority of borrowings pertaining to nautical, commercial, military and royal domains come from Persian rather than Arabic. Persian influence is further evident in Malay literature and Sufism, which manifest concepts and styles from Persian antecedents. Arabic words form the lion’s share of borrowings in the domain of religion and aspects of daily life influenced by Islamic teachings, which is expected and does not theoretically require the presence of an Arabic-speaking community. Persian was the vector of transmission for many Arabic words into Malay, which is revealed by the presence of idiosyncratic Persian phonological and semantic mutations to those Arabic words. More interesting is the absence of ‘pure’ Arabic loans in certain domains, particularly in informal speech including colloquial and explicit terms (compare Malay bedebah “damned; fuck it!” from Persian بدبخت badbakht; biadab “rude” from Persian بى ادب biadab; betah “comfortable; feeling better” from Persian بهتر behtar “better”; haram jadah from حرام‌زاده harāmzādah “bastard”; lahanat “damn!” from Persian لعنت la’nat “curse, damn”; syabas from شاباش šābāš “well done!”; etc.), which raises doubt whether Arabic was ever used as a language of communication. Nonetheless, the persistence of few but important Persian words alongside Arabic equivalents in the religious sphere bolsters the historic importance of Persianate Islamic culture on the Malay-Indonesian Archipelago:

MalayPersianEnglish
Abdasآبدست ābdastAblution (wudu’); compare Hui Chinese 阿布代斯 ā-bù-dài-sī, also from Persian
Bangبانگ
bāng
Islamic call to prayer (adhan); compare Hui Chinese 邦克 bāng-kè, also from Persian
Dargahدرگاه dargāhShrine associated with a Muslim saint
Darwisدرویش‎ darvišAn indigent, ascetic person; a Sufi
Langgarلنگر langarA small mosque
Periپرى
pari
Fairy

Moroccan Darija (Casablancan Koiné): A Historical Approach

Written by Afsheen Sharifzadeh, a graduate of Tufts University focusing on Iran and the Caucasus. The goal of this article is to explore the origins of Moroccan Darija through the lens of local sedentary and Bedouin dialects, and to examine historic contacts with autochthonous Berber languages and foreign languages such as Spanish and Persian.

The main courtyard and its reflection pool, Ibn Youssef madrasa and mosque complex, Marrakesh, Morocco (c. 1564 A.D)

Background

Northwest Africa (the “Maghreb”, from Arabic المغرب الاقصى al-maġrib al-aqṣa “the farthest West”; and, more recently, Berber: ⵜⴰⵎⴰⵣⵖⴰ Tamazɣa “Land of the Imazighen [Berbers]”) experienced two waves of Arabization separated in time by nearly five centuries. Following a classification made by Ibn Khaldūn, the first wave was composed of mainly urban soldiers while the second wave brought thousands of nomadic Arabian families to the region. The number of Arabophones who arrived in both waves must have been small beside the indigenous Berber-speaking population (still partly Latin-speaking in the towns of the old Roman coast), and whilst many Berbers shifted to the language of their conquerors over the centuries, this process has failed to result in the adoption of an exclusively Arab identity. 

Arabic vernaculars in Morocco, Algeria and Tunisia are referred to locally as Darija (lit. “the current speech; vernacular language”), while the literary Arabic standard used in education, broadcast and administration is called al-ʕarabiyya al-fuṣḥā (lit. “the most eloquent Arabic”). Darija varieties may in turn be divided into sedentary (pre-Hilali, or مديني mdīni lit. “urban”, or حضري ħadˤari “settled”) and Bedouin (Hilali or عروبي ʕarūbi, lit. “Arabian”) dialects. However, these descriptors technically refer to the medieval “Middle Eastern” vernaculars from which they descend rather than the lifestyles of their current speakers. While there is largely direct lineage between the progenitor Middle Eastern urban dialects and Moroccan urban dialects, in some cases, they do not correspond. For example, the Jebli Arabic dialect spoken in the northwestern rim of the Atlas mountains represents a “sedentary” (Pre-Hilali) dialect adopted by Berber mountaineers along the trade routes between Fes and Tangier, which therefore links it more closely with the old urban dialects of North Africa. Moreover, Moroccan Darija, which originated in 20th century Casablanca and is now the lingua franca of the country, is of Bedouin provenance (discussed below).

To further complicate the linguistic landscape in Morocco, sedentary and Bedouin Arabic varieties have interacted individually with neighboring Berber languages for over a millennium. The sedentary (Pre-Hilali) Arabic dialects, representing the first layer of Arabization, are the most innovative and bear the strongest morphosyntactic traces of these contacts. In contrast, Bedouin dialects were chiefly influenced by Berber phonetic and semantic interferences. The sedentary varieties are marked, further, by a stratum of Hispanisms, carried by the Muslim and Jewish refugees of the successive Iberian expulsions, culminating in 1492 and in the Morisco expulsion of 1609, who settled overwhelmingly in the cities; the Bedouin dialects of the countryside lay outside the refugees’ orbit, and the Spanish words accordingly stop at the city walls.

Moroccan Darija, which can be used interchangeably with “Casablancan Koine”, arose recently as a product of rapid urbanization around Casablanca in the 20th century. The dialect is of Bedouin provenance, owing to the origin of most Casablancans, but it features a strong admixture of Pre-Hilali elements brought by old urban elites who migrated from Fes, Rabat, Salé, Meknès and other northern cities. It is thus a modern koine, precipitated from many streams of migration, and the continuation of no single historically attested dialect. Although it is now the mother language of a plurality of Moroccans, there still exists a significant degree of variation within the speech community, owing to its rather recent genesis and the varied regional origins of its speakers. At times, such as in the case of Fessis, Koine speakers have purposefully transferred certain features of their ancestral lects (e.g. Fessi use of non-trilled [ɹ], emphasized occlusive laryngeal  [ʔˤ] or [q] in lieu of Bedouin [g], and gender-neutralized second person pronoun انتينا intīna in the perfective and imperfective aspects) because these features had long signified urbane refinement and, therefore, prestige.

Painted wood or Tazouaqt (Arabic: تزواقت, from Berber ⵜⴰⵣⵡⵡⴰⵇⵜ) at the entrance to the mausoleum of Moulay Idriss II in Fez, Morocco (c. 1440 A.D., almost completely replaced in the 18th century by Moulay Ismail in a style typical of the Alaouites )

Sedentary (pre-Hilalian) Arabic dialects:

The first wave of Arabs arrived armed on horseback, apparently without their families, in the 7th century AD. This band was composed of mixed urban Arabians (presumably Meccans) and “Middle Eastern” Muslim converts–soldiers hailing from Syria, Mesopotamia, Persia, Egypt and elsewhere–who introduced Perso-Arabian Islamic material culture and sedentary Arabic varieties to Roman Africa, the two Mauretaniæ and Hispania. In 670 A.D., the city of Kairouane (from Middle Persian 𐭪𐭠𐭫𐭥𐭠𐭭 kārawān “military column; caravan”) was established as a headquarters for the Muslims’ expansionist ambitions in the region, wherefrom they “plunged into the heart of the country, traversed the wilderness in which his successors erected the splendid capitals of Fes and…[Marrakesh], and at length penetrated to the verge of the Atlantic and the great desert” (Edward Gibbon). It deserves remark that the very seat of Islamization in the Maghreb bears a Persian name.

The newcomers, numbering, it seems, only in the few thousands, exchanged extensively with their Berber-speaking neighbors, who must have greatly outnumbered them. In the culinary sphere they took up local foods, couscous first among them (Berber ⵙⴻⴽⵙⵓ seksu → Arabic كسكسو ksksu “couscous”) and in return, they transferred tastes from the orient (particularly Persian cuisine, discussed below). However, owing to the very fact of their small numbers, apparently not enough correct Arabic input was available to language learners, which resulted in significant interference from Berber in the learning process. For example, it has been suggested that the agentive m- prefix arose due to overgeneralization of a corresponding Berber agentic prefix (ⴰⵎ am-) with a broader scope of use in the first stages of language learning (e.g. مزيان mzyān “good” from زين zayn; including exceptional cases that are actually derived from Berber roots; e.g. Shilha ⴰⵎⵥⵍⵓⴹ amẓluḍ “poor” → مزلط məzluṭ “poor”). The fəʕʕāl noun class tells the same story from the other side: unproductive in Classical Arabic, where it is confined to occupations (نجار nəjjār “carpenter”), it was seized upon by Berber bilinguals as though it were the general participle, and Darija now says xəwwāf “fearful” on the pattern of “carpenter”

This wave was followed by a period of intense Islamization of the “pagan” autochthones, whilst per Quranic prescriptions the ahl al-ḏh̲imma (Iberian Christians and Jews, and the Jews of the Berber lands) were largely left alone. For centuries thereafter Arabs and Berbers lived in uneasy communion, the latter frequently serving as clients to the former, until various Berber-led rebellions toppled the Umayyad Caliphate by the middle of the 8th century. Arabic vernaculars remained essentially confined to the cities the Arabs inhabited, while in the countryside Berber languages remained the means of inter-community communications until present times. The turning point came in the 9th century, after the foundation of Fes as the Idrisid capital: thousands of refugees from Andalusia and from Kairouan settled in the city, founding its great mosques and madrasas (al-Andalusiyyin “of the Andalusians” and al-Qarawiyyin lit. “of the Kairouanians” mosques, c. 859 A.D.). In a sociolinguistic sense the influx meant that there was suddenly abundant native Arabic input available to learners, as well as a social motivation to speak “pure” Arabic, which favored the leveling of salient Berber transferences. It probably served to reverse the process of creolization in urban dialects which had been underway before this period. However, the few exceptional items that survived were probably too frequent by that time to be leveled by prescriptive Arabic influences (e.g. مزيان mzyān “good”; جوج juj “two”; imperative اجي aji “come!” through elimination of irregular تعال taʕāl “come).

The urban Arabic dialects in Morocco which descend from the first wave of Arabization include those of Fes, Salé, Rabat, Meknès, Marrakesh, Tétouane, Chefchaouen, Tangier, Ouazzane, Taza, as well as the Jebli dialects in the Rif region. Across modern political borders, the dialects of most old cities in the Maghreb (Tlemcen, Constantine, Tunis, Kairouane, Oran, Tripoli etc.) are included in this group. Although a minority dialect, Fessi Arabic enjoys prestige in Morocco to this day, for it is the speech of the old urban patriciate, the merchant and scholarly families of Fes; and when that class migrated over the last century to Casablanca, drawn by the new economic capital and its French schools, it carried the dialect with it as a mark of station.The core vocabulary of the urban Arabic varieties in the Maghreb often corresponds to urban dialects further east, such as in the case of Fessi Arabic, vis-à-vis Casablancan Koine which is of Bedouin provenance:

EnglishMoroccan DarijaFessi ArabicDamascene Arabic
“He did”dārɛamalʕamal
“I liked”bġitḥabbitabbeyt
“heart”gəlbʔalb*ʔalb
“What’s your name?”ašnu smītekšnu ʔesmekšu ʔesmek
“Listen!”nnitsmaʕismaʕ
“Good”mzyānmli, mzyānmni
“Here! (take this!)”hākkhūdkhud
*Classical Arabic qalb with /q/ is also used

Pre-Hilali dialects like Fessi and, through influence, Casablanca Koine, make the most use of analytic morphology such as the analytic genitive instead of the constructed genitive which is used in ʕarūbi lects. A few salient Pre-Hilali morphologic innovations are listed below:

  1. In Koine, the construct genitive is no longer productive and is used only in certain relatively frozen constructions, having been replaced by dyāl or d(e.g. L-malek d’l-mghrib “The King of Morocco”).
    1. Some ʕarūbi glosses with the constructed genitive are preferred in Koine (akhūti “my brothers”) in contrast to the more innovative Pre-Hilali forms used in the northern city dialects (khāwa dyāli “ibid.”)
  2. Analytic elatives using ktar “more” have replaced the Classical Arabic afʕal construction : bnīn ktar “tastier” instead of *abnan
  3. Indefinite singular nouns employ a gender neutralized prefix واحد ال wad l- in lieu of a gendered suffix (this development parallels the Medieval Baghdadi prefix فد fad “a” from فرد fard)
  4. An analytic dual construction emerged which has supplanted the inherited suffixed dual. It uses the word جوج juj “two” (from Classical Arabic زوج zawj “pair; couple” < Greek ζεῦγος zeûgos “yoke” via Aramaic ܙܘܓܐ zawgā). 
  5. The feminine singular agreement for inanimate plurals in Classical Arabic was replaced by masculine gender and plural number: bināyāt zuwīnīn “beautiful buildings” (cf. Classical Arabic bināyāt jamīla)
EnglishMoroccan DarijaModern Standard Arabic
“Beautiful things”Shiwāyej zuwīnīnAshyāʔ jamila
“Many things”Bzzāf dyāl wāyejAshyāʔ kaīra 
“Tasty, tastier”Bnīn, bnīn ktarLaḏīḏ, alaḏḏ
“One man”Waḥd r-rajelRajul wāḥed
“Two women”juj d’l-ʕiyālātimraʔatān
“Our house is more beautiful than their house”D-dār dyālna zuwīna ktar mn d-dār dyālhumBaytuna ajmal min baytihim

As in the other dialects, new formations arose from native Arabic materials, albeit with little concordance with the eastern Arabic idioms: باش bāš “in order to”, from بِأَيِّ شَيْء‎ (biʾayyi šayʾ, “with what thing”); لاباس labās “well, good” from Arabic لَا بَأْسَ‎ (lā baʾsa), the verb noun of بَؤُسَ‎ baʾusa “damage, calamity”; كاين kāyin “there exists” (from كائن kā’en “existing”; cf. Medieval Baghdadi Arabic اكو aku from يكون yakūn). Some further innovations include:

  1. Use of ka- or the variant ta- for progressive tense; e.g. ka-nktəb “I write”, ta-tbġini “You love me”
  2. The future tense is constructed using ġādi or simply ġa- (cf. Classical Arabic ġadan “tomorrow”)
  3. First person marker with n- and first person plural use of prefix n- + suffix -u; e.g. nmši “I go”, nmšiu “We go”. This reshaping of the inherited paradigm is the signature isogloss of western Arabic idioms, from Libya to Morocco to the Arabic of medieval Sicily and al-Andalus.
  4. Gender has been leveled in the 2nd person singular perfect, with the feminine ending generalized (-i) (note: Pre-Hilali dialects use an immutable pronoun intīna with the masculine 2nd person perfect verb ending)
EnglishMoroccan DarijaMuslim Baghdadi ArabicDamascene Arabic
“I just came to tell you that I love you very much”Ġīr jīt bāš ngullək ka-nbġīk bzzāf (variant ta-nbġīk)Bas ijeet ʕalamud agullak innu āni aebbek hwāye Bas ijet ʕashān aʔullak innī baḥebbak ktīr
“There is or there isn’t”Kāyen wla ma kāyenšAku lo mākuFī aw mā fī
“I will dance too”Ḥta ana ġādi nšaĀni ham ra arguṣAna ra arʔuṣ kamān
“Because”Ḥet, ḥetāš liʔanleʔannu
“We wanted to sleep there”Kenna nbġīu nnəʕʕsu təmmākČinna nrīd ənnām əhnākeKān biddna nnām hunīk
“If you were a true Moroccan, you shouldn’t have sold your country to foreigners”Kūn kenti maḡribi quḥḥ, kūn ma bʕtiš l-blād dyālek lgwarLo činit maghrebi ḥaqiqi, ma chān baʕet blādek lil faranj Iza kent maghrebi aʔiʔi, ma kān beʕt baladak lil faranj

On the Persian Elements in Morocco

Old urban dialects, such as that of Fes, have imbued Moroccan Darija with words of early imperial Islamic origin which recall the Orient, including: بالزاف bzzāf “very; a lot” (from Classical Arabic بالجزاف bil jazāf, itself from Persian گزاف gazāf “exaggerated, excessive”) and ڭاوري gāwri (from Persian گاور gâvor “Zoroastrian from Mesopotamia”; later adopted by the Muslims meaning “infidel”), كفتة kafta (from Persian كوفته kūfte, كوفتن kūftan “to beat, grind, shatter”), شوربة shurba “soup” (from Persian شوربا šurbâ “a kind of stew”, lit. “salty/sour stew”); مݣانة magāna “clock, watch” from Persian پنگان pengān “water clock” (cf. Tunisian Arabic منڨالة mungāla), شرجم،سرجب sarjam/sharjab “window”  from Persian چارچوب čârčub “frame”; note Libyan Arabic  روشن‎ rōšan, “window” from Persian روزن rowzan‎ “crevice, hole”); بزطام bizṭām (cf. Algerian Arabic تزدام tezdām) from Persian جزدان jozdān “wallet”; سطوان siṭwān “tiled courtyard surrounded by peristyle within the house” (from Persian ستون sotun “column”); خرشوف xarshūf “artichoke” (from Middle Persian 𐭤𐭠𐭫𐭰𐭥𐭯 *xār-čōp, lit. “thorny stick”), خمم xemmem “to think” (irregular variant with -m final of Classical Arabic خمن xammana “to guess, suspect”, maybe ultimately an assimilated root from Persian گمان gumān “supposition; speculation”). Urban dialects like that of Salé have preserved other Abbasid archaisms, such as مارستان māristān “hospital”, from Persian بيمارستان bimārestān. A later Ottoman-mediated Persian stratum is also discernible: طربوش ṭarbūsh “fez hat” (from Persian سرپوش sar-pūš “head-cover”), beside the much older بابوش bābūsh “slipper” (from Persian پاپوش pā-pūš “foot-cover”).

(1) A Moroccan man clad in traditional striped jeleba fills a bottle of water at Fontaine Nejjarine, Fes, Morocco (c. 18th century) (2) Horseshoe arches with polychrome glazed tiles decorate the Bab Bou Jeloud (built by the French in 1913), with a view of the Bou Inania minaret and old medina, Fes, Morocco (3) Polychrome glazed tiles with geometric motifs, resembling those in Persian architecture, at Dar el Bacha museum, Marrakesh, Morocco (4) The author (right) and his brother in Fes, Morocco (c. 1998)

The presence of Iranian loans might at first seem unremarkable, given the many hundreds of Persian words that entered Arabic itself, directly or through Aramaic, after the Islamic conquest of Sasanian Persia. Persian, Greek, and Aramaic are the principal donor languages of Classical Arabic, though only the latter two are commonly emphasized; and Persians played a seminal role in the standardization of Arabic as a literary medium, a primacy the Arab historiographer Ibn Khaldūn himself recorded in detail. On that account, a Persian word in Moroccan speech should be no more surprising than one in Cairo or Damascus. But the words assembled below resist that explanation: many are unattested in the Arabic vernaculars further east. Had they traveled inside common Arabic, they would be found wherever Arabic is found; their confinement to the Maghreb indicates instead that they arrived by their own road, and, taken together with the material and onomastic evidence detailed below, points to a small but influential Iranian element in early Islamic North Africa.

In light of the drastic shortage of historical records on these migrations, the presence of Persian names among intellectuals and dynasts of the Islamic period in North Africa lends credence to that idea. Apparently their descendants founded two dynasties in the Maghreb–the Rustamids (777–909 A.D.) were Persian Ibāḍī imāms, founded by ʿAbd al-Raḥmān ibn Rustam, whose very name preserves that of the Shāhnāmeh’s great hero; their capital Tahert, in modern-day Algeria, was known to contemporaries as ʿIrāq al-Maghrib, “Mesopotamia of the West”, and even Balkh al-Maghrib, “Bactria of the West”, and it is telling that when men sought a comparison for the city, they reached for the Iranian east. A century and a half later, the Khurāsānid dynasty (Bānū-Khurāsān, 1059-1148 A.D.) founded by ‘Abd al-Ḥaqq ibn ‘Abd al-‘Aziz ibn Khurāsān and, as the name suggests, of reputed Khurāsānī descent, ruled an independent principality in modern-day Tunisia. Persian immigrants or those with Iranian nisbas appear further afield in Andalusia (e.g. Ziryāb), detailed below. 

A Persian Kharijite Ibāḍī imām, Abd al-Raḥmān ibn Rustam, and his descendants ruled the Rustamid (Bānū-Bādūsyān) dynasty in the Maghreb (777-909 A.D). Its capital, Tahert, became a Kharijite stronghold famed as ‘Iraq al-Maghrib “Mesopotamia of the West”, or Balkh al-Maghrib “Bactria of the West”, perhaps owing to the Iranian character of the city and some of its inhabitants. A century after its fall, another Iranian dynasty, the Khurāsānids (1059-1148 A.D), came to power in northern Tunisia

It is notable that west of Baghdād (from Middle Persian 𐭡𐭢𐭣𐭲‎ (bgdt /bag-dād/, “given by god”; compare Russian given name Богда́н Bogdan “ibid.”), nowhere in the medieval Islamic world did Iranian forms gain such currency as in the Maghreb. Perhaps this owed in part to the nature of urbanity in Anatolia, Egypt, Palestine and Greater Syria, where for centuries the materials of Greco-Roman civilization reigned supreme among a Romanized Christian citizenry. Indeed Roman churches and civic buildings in these regions were frequently dismantled by the Muslims for reusable materials or converted to mosques, sometimes by little more than the addition of a mihrab and minaret (e.g. the Umayyad Mosque of Damascus which was formerly the Basilica of Saint John the Baptist; Greek: βασιλική του Αγίου Ιοάννή του Βαπτιστή Vasilikí tou Agíou Ioánni tou Vaptistí). Islamic architectural forms in these regions employed nearly identical building materials (limestone ashlar) and ornamentation schemes (marble veneer decorations, Greek order columns) to the forms that preceded them, which were Roman in character. 

The Maghreb was by contrast comparatively virgin ground for the Muslim immigrants, who founded a significant number of new cities which they cohabited with Berbers. These new spaces invited the transmission and local innovation of eastern architectural vocabulary, fashions and culinary stylings. For example, the adoption of the quadripartite Persian garden form (Persian: چهار باغ chahār bāgh; Arabic: رياض riāḍ), itself an ancient Iranian inheritance, was most marked in the Maghreb, and it became a prominent feature in Moorish palaces in Spain (such as at Madinat al-Zaḥrā, the Aljafería, and the Alhambra). In the 9th century, the potters of Iran had learned to fire colored tiles with metallic pigments over a glaze of tin oxide, which heralded a renaissance of majolica tile production in the Persianate world and reached, it seems, as far as the Maghreb. The technique behind Maghrebi zellīj, the firing of glazed and lustered tile, belongs on this evidence to the Persianate tradition, whatever the local genius that later shaped it into cut-tile mosaic; and the rival derivation, that the figural Roman mosaic of tesserae depicting humans and animals somehow fathered the abstract Islamic zellīj, strains belief. The latter hypothesis demands, further, that Persian and Maghrebi tilework, strikingly alike in composition and design, arose twice over, at one moment, and each in ignorance of the other. And it must then explain why the art was absent in Syria, Palestine or Egypt, where Roman and Byzantine mosaics stood in the greatest abundance, and appeared instead at the far end of the Mediterranean, where they were fewest.

Evidence of Persian craftsmen and architects exporting their crafts abounds in the Arab world; for example, the glazed tiles on several Cairene buildings, including the bulbous stone minarets of the mosque of Nāṣer Moḥammad in the citadel (1318-35 A.D.), indicate that craftsmen from Tabrīz operated a workshop in Cairo in the 1330s and 1340s. Double-shelled, ribbed domes ending in muqarnas corbels (stalactites) with high drums banded with calligraphy are Persian features to be seen on the Mausoleum of al-Ṣultaniyya in Cairo, and which are later encountered in Timurid Samarqand. What the Maghreb took from this eastern current, however, was selective. The characteristic Persian four-ayvān plan, which conquered the madrasas of Egypt and Anatolia, was not adopted in the far Maghreb, whose madrasas kept the single courtyard; it was instead the Persianate surface arts that took hold. For example muqarnas, an occasional imported grace-note in Cairo, became in the west a native industry, carved in stucco to a refinement that culminated in the honeycomb vaults of the Alhambra. Moreover the Maghreb built, as Persia built, predominantly in baked earth and brick, surfaces that invite glazed tile and carved plaster, whereas Egypt and Syria built in limestone ashlar dressed with marble veneer, surfaces that refuse them. Thus Persian elements appeared throughout Maghrebi architecture, and by no mysterious route: men who had seen Persian buildings, and men trained by them, must have been present in North Africa to build from memory.

A Persian-style arched ayvān with muqarnas vaulting and polychrome glazed tiles, Bou Inania Madrasa, Fes, Morocco (1350-55 A.D.). Elements of Persian architecture and ornamentation form a foundation for Maghrebi Islamic forms.

Moroccan culinary tradition attributes the widespread use of nuts like almonds, pistachios and walnuts, dried fruits such as raisins, prunes, dates and apricots, pickled lemons (حامض مصير ḥamudh mṣir) and saffron to Persian influence. Indeed, the two cuisines share an idiosyncratic palette, sweet, savory and sour in one dish, that sets each apart from its immediate neighbors. Moreover, it is known that Muslims introduced saffron from Persia to North Africa in the 10th century. The pattern is the same one the loanwords show: forms that are faint or absent in Egypt and Syria appear full-strength in the Maghreb, as though the current had passed through the intervening lands without settling there; and the likeliest carriers are, again, the few but influential Iranians among the early Muslims of the west.

A variation of Moroccan ṭājin barquq w meshmāsh with mutton, prunes, apricots, raisins, sesames, cinnamon and pistachios. Maghrebi cuisine shares an idiosyncratic sweet, savory and sour palette with Persian cuisine, probably reflecting the introduction of Persian ingredients and flavors by the Muslims.

It appears, then, that a thin but consequential Iranian thread runs through the foundation layer of Islamic North Africa, legible at once in the name of its first city (Kairouane), in two of its dynasties (the Rustamids and the Khurāsānids), in a loan stratum, in the Persian garden form, in architectural vocabulary and a tile tradition, and in cuisine. Indeed, the thread was taken up again, centuries later, when Ottoman rule brought a second wave of Persianate civilization to Algiers, Tunis, Tripoli, and other urban centers.

Andalusian Influence

From the 15th century onward, the old Maghrebi cities (particularly Tangier, Fes and Rabat, and more broadly Constantine, Tlemcen, Kairouan, Tunis, Tripoli and Bizerte) received a massive influx of Muslims and Jews expelled from Islamic Spain (Arabic الاندلسيين al-Andalusiyyīn; the final wave, the nominally converted Moriscos, arriving after the expulsion of 1609), who migrated “back” to a Maghreb most had never seen and settled among their distant dialectal cousins. This second urbanite wave further shaped the urban dialects, while leaving the ʕarūbi speech of the countryside largely untouched. Andalusian families, still distinguished by their surnames–Jorio, Fenjiro, Chkalante, Guedira, Gharnaṭa, Qorṭoubi, Andalousi, Prado, Vergas, Lavra–brought features of Spanish and Andalusian Arabic to the local vernaculars. The ​​طرب أندلسي ṭarab ʾandalusī (and by extension غرناطي gharnāṭi “Granadan” in Tlemcen, from the Arabic name for Granada) is attributed to a certain Ziryāb, a freed Persian slave-turned-courtier and musical pioneer who introduced Persian instruments and musical modes to Muslim Spain. The Andalusian repertoire, with its foundations in classical Persian and Spanish music, is thus distinguished from ʕarūbi (what has been termed shaʕbi “folk”), Gnāwa and Berber folk music, which employ different instruments, formats and modes. The Gnāwa repertoire in particular, which features the guembri lute and the call-and-response format of vocal performance, links it with the musical systems of the Songhay in Timbuktu, Gao and Djenné.

A number of old Iberian Romance words entered the Fessi dialect, the legacy of large numbers of Andalusian Muslim and Jewish refugees who migrated to Maghrebian cities after their expulsion from Islamic Spain, some of which have been adopted in Casablancan Koine. These include سيمانة simāna “week” from Spanish semana; Fessi كوشينة kušina “kitchen” from Spanish cocina (doublet with darija كوزينة kuzina, probably a later borrowing during the Spanish protectorate); اشكولة iškuila “school”; from Spanish escuela; قرة qirra from Spanish guerra “war”; فورنو furnu “oven” from Spanish forno; شلية šelya “chair” from Spanish silla; طابلة ṭabla “table” from Spanish tabla; فيشطة fishṭa “party”, from Spanish fiesta; كريلو grīllu “cockroach” from Spanish grillo “cricket”; قميجة qamija “shirt”, from Spanish camisa; بسطيلة basṭila from Spanish pastilla “puff pastry with various fillings”; فابور fābor “free [of charge]; a favor” from Spanish favor; rwina from Spanish ruina “mess, wreck”, qīmrūn “shrimp” from Spanish camarón. In cities like Salé where the Andalusians settled, Spanish words penetrated even the core vocabulary, though these items have not passed into the koine, owing to their salient foreign nature:

EnglishSalawi Arabic (Salé)Spanish
“Good”buinubueno
“Wrong”falo falso
“Luck”as-suirtisuerte 
“Alone”ulusolo

The descendants of the Andalusian Jews, who called themselves megorashim, “the expelled”, retained their Judeo-Spanish vernacular (Ḥaketía and Ladino) in the northern cities until the community’s dispersal, to Israel, France and the Americas, in the mid-20th century.

Bedouin (Hilalian) or ʕarūbi Dialects: the Basis of Moroccan Darija

The second wave of Arabic speakers were Bedouins of the Banu Maʕqil, Banu Hilal, Banu Sulaym and Bani Ḥassan tribes who migrated en masse in the 11th and 12th centuries from the Najd region of Arabia to the Maghreb, where they took home in the arid plains and hautes-plateaux. The impetus for this forced migration was the Fatimid Caliphate’s desire to confine the unruly Bedouins in the south of their dominion. As the Bedouins were unaccustomed to urbanity, the Banu Hilal settled in areas where they continued their nomadic lifestyle, and this wave brought significantly greater linguistic arabization and spread of nomadism in areas where agriculture had previously dominated. Camps (1983) estimates the number of Bedouins to have been relatively small; only around 80,000 at the outset, and their migration extended over two centuries and not all of them settled in Morocco. Local Berbers (most likely belonging to the Masmuda confederacy and thus speaking a language related to Shilha, given the Bedouins’ settlement in the lowlying plains between Souss and Rabat), who shared a similar lifestyle of pastoralism, were quickly assimilated to the language of the incomers. The nature of their contact was such that, over time, the Arabs adopted the modified Arabic of their Berber neighbors and started to speak it amongst themselves. The whole community then passed this speech to its children, and the learners’ variety became the mother tongue of all. With the establishment of Casablanca, it was the ʕarūbi migrant workers and their dialects, rather than the old sedentary dialects such as Fessi, that became the basis of Moroccan Darija.

A Bedouin camp in the desert near Merzouga, Morocco

In contrast to the sedentary dialects which use the local innovation ka- or ta-, ʕarūbi dialects particularly in northeastern Morocco and Algeria developed a progressive aspect marker and by extension copula -را rā (lit. “he saw”), probably from Najdi ترا tarā “to be seen” : e.g. ni nkteb = “I am writing” (lit. “He saw me writing”); rāk mn wjda “you are from Oujda”. Some comparisons between Moroccan Darija and Najdi Arabic are made below:

EnglishMoroccan Darija (Oujda)Najdi Arabic
“Youth, young generation”drāridhrāri
Interrogative particle wəšweš
“What my heart wanted (f.)”Lli bġaha gəlbiIlli bġaha galbi
“Take this”hākhā
“She is going”Rāha tmšiTarāha temši

With regard to Berber elements in ʕarūbi (Bedouin) dialects, examples of both metatypy and phonological restructuring exist, which is possible in extended and complex contact situations. The Arabization process presumably started with the Arabs’ neighbors, and then these Arabized Berbers served as intermediaries to their next neighbors, etc.  A few examples of Berber metatypy in ʕarūbi are listed below:

  1. The Berber feminine/diminutive circumfix ta….t used mainly with nouns of occupations in Moroccan Darija (e.g. bənnay “mason” –> tabənnayət “profession of masonry”) but also for abstract noun derivations, e.g. dərri “child” –> tadərrit “childhood”
  2. The Berber genitive marker n “of”, though limited to some kinship terms like bb°a n Sufiān “father of Soufiane”

On Berber (Amazigh) influences in Darija

Berber (endonym: ⵜⴰⵎⴰⵣⵉⵖⵜ tamazīɣt; Ar. الامازيغية al-amazīġīyya; الشلحة aššilḥa) is a distinct language family belonging to the Afro-Asiatic phylum. Blench (2018) notes that Berber is considerably different from other Afroasiatic branches, and indeed its genetic relation to Arabic–of equal magnitude to its relation with Ancient Egyptian and Cushitic–is vanishingly remote. Proto-Berber probably split from a common ancestor with the other known Afro-Asiatic branches between ~10,000-9,000 years before present, and then this group underwent a putative linguistic bottleneck as recently as ~3,000 years ago, which apparently eradicated the internal diversity of the family and left a contracted number of idioms from which all of the modern Berber languages descend. Proto-Berber then appears to have spread across a vast area from the western banks of the Nile river to the Atlantic coast of North Africa. Today, an estimated 30-40% of Moroccans, 20-30% of Algerians, 5-10% of Libyans and 1% of Tunisians use a Berber language as a mother tongue, but these numbers would have been higher only a century ago. 

A map showing the modern distribution of languages belonging to the Afro-Asiatic macrofamily. Berber languages (purple) were indigenous languages to Northwest Africa prior to the arrival of Arabic. Today, an estimated 30-40% of Moroccans, 20-30% of Algerians, 5-10% of Libyans and 1% of Tunisians use a Berber language as a mother tongue.

The region was visited from an early date by seafaring Phoenician merchants from the Eastern Mediterranean (but, apparently, few Greeks), who established important port colonies (e.g. Shilha ⴰⴳⴰⴷⵉⵔ Agadir, from Phoenician 𐤂𐤃𐤓‎ gādīr “wall;compound”, cognate with Arabic جدار jidār “wall”; Rusadir from Phoenician 𐤓‬𐤔𐤀𐤃𐤓‬ rushādir “powerful). These immigrants later established the Carthaginian empire and perpetuated Punic language and culture, eventually subjugating the Romanized para-Berber kingdom of Numidia. The presence of Punic borrowings in Proto-Berber points to the diversification of modern Berber language varieties subsequent to the fall of Carthage in 146 B.C.; only Guanche and Zenaga lack Punic loanwords. Berberophones along the Mediterranean coast later became subjects of the Roman Empire under administrative divisions of Tripolitania, Africa, Mauretania Caesariensis and Mauretania Tingitana, but commercial and cultural exchanges between Romans and Berbers along the Līmes Mauretaniæ persisted for centuries through the Byzantine period. 

During this age of contact, Roman innovations including the ox-plough, camel (Kabyle: ⴰⵍⵖⵯⵎ a-lɣəm via metathesis from Latin camēlus or Coptic ϭⲁⲙⲟⲩⲗ (camoul)?), and orchard management were adopted by Berber communities. Latin loanwords in Berber include, notably, ⴰⴼⵓⵍⵍⵓⵙ afullus “chicken” (from Latin pullus); ⴰⵙⵏⵓⵙ asnus “donkey” (from Latin asinus), ⵓⵔⵜⵉ urti “garden” (from Latin hortus); ⵜⴰⵖⴰⵡⵙⴰ taɣawsa “thing” (from Latin causa “reason/case; motive”); ⴰⵏⵖⴰⵍⵓⵙ anɣalus “angel, spiritual entity” (from Latin angelus); ⵉⴳⴻⵔ iger “cultivated field” (from Latin ager); ⵜⴰⴼⴰⵙⴽⴰ tafaska “feast/religious celebration” (from Latin pascha “Easter; Passover”); ⴰⴼⴰⵍⴽⵓ afalku “bearded vulture” (from Latin falcō “falcon”), ⵜⴰⴼⴻⵙⵏⴰⵅⵜ tafesnaxt “carrot” (from Latin pastinaca “parsnip, stingray”), ⵢⴻⵏⵏⴰⵢⴻⵔ yennayer “January; first month of the Berber New Year” (from Latin ianuarius), inter alia.

(Top) Ruins of the Basilica of Volubilis; (Bottom left) Roman mosaics at Volubilis; (Bottom right) Storks nesting atop Corinthian-order columns at Volubilis, Morocco

Berber is the substrate language for the Arabic varieties spoken in the Maghreb. Nonetheless, it has left few lexical borrowings in Arabic varieties, with the most notable exception of toponyms. The overwhelming majority of place names in Morocco are of Berber origin, e.g. ⴰⵎⵓⵔ ⵏ ⴰⴽⵓⵛ amur n akush “Land of God”, whence Marrakesh and Morocco; ⵉⵎⵉ ⵏ ⵜⴰⵏⵓⵜ imi n tanout  “mouth of a small well”, ⵉⴼⵔⴰⵏ ifran “caves”; ⴰⵎⴽⵏⴰⵙ amknas whence Meknes “the Miknasa Zenata Berber tribe”; ⵜⵉⵟⵟⴰⵡⴰⵏ tiṭṭawan “springs” (with the Ghomara Berber feminine plural suffix ⴰⵏ –an) whence Tetouane; ⵜⵉⵏⴳⵉ tingi “marsh”, whence Tangier; ⵡⵔ ⴰⵣⵣⴰⵣⴰⵜ ur azzazat “without clamor; silent” whence Ouarzatate, etc.

Other ancient local words may include ݣناوة gnāwa “Sub-Saharan Africans and their musical repertoire in Morocco; a caste of largely endogamous black Africans living among both Arabophones and Berberophones”, probably from a Shilha gloss ⴰⴳⵏⴰⵡ agnaw “deaf-mute” (pl. ⵉⴳⵏⴰⵡⵏ ignawen) and later “black people” (semantic development resembles Arabic عجم ‘ajam “confusing or unclear way of speaking” → “Persians”). This word is probably also the origin of “Guinea” and perhaps “Djenné”.

A speaker of the Senhaja d’Srair Berber language, spoken in the Ketama commune of Al Hoceïma Province, in the central part of the Rif mountains. Despite its geographic proximity to and influence from the neighboring Riffian Berber language, Senhaja Berber together with nearby Ghomara belong to the Atlas group, linking them to the Shilha and Central Atlas Tamazight languages further south.

In the domestic and culinary spheres, there exist a few important loanwords: كسكسو ksksu “couscous” from Berber ⵙⴻⴽⵙⵓ seksu; ساروت sārūt “key”, from Central Atlas Berber ⵜⴰⵙⴰⵔⵓⵜ tasarut; and صيفط ṣīfṭ “to send” (cf. Kabyle ⵙⵙⵉⴼⴻⴹ ssifeḍ). Some local flora and fauna have also retained their Berber names: زايس zāyis “octopus” from Berber ⴰⵣⴰⵢⵣ azayz; مشّ mušš “cat” (cf. Central Atlas Tamazight ⴰⵎⵓⵛⵛ amušš); لالة Lalla “lady; respected woman”, (related to Central Atlas Berber ⴰⵍⴰⵍⵍⵓ alallu “dignity”, from ⵜⵉⵍⴻⵍⵍⵉ tilelli “freedom”); دشار dšār from ⴷⵛⴰⵔ dšar “region”; شلاغم šlāḡem “mustache” from Berber ⴰⵛⵍⵖⵓⵎ ašlɣum

It is possible that the use of feminine gender language names in Darija is Berber substrate: الريفية al-rifiyya “Riffian language”, cf. ⵜⴰⵔⵉⴼⵉⵜ Tarifit “Riffian language”. Additionally, Moroccan Darija exhibits a preference for broken plurals, particularly for ethnonyms or nationalities endemic to the region. By contrast, geographically distant peoples use the regular jarr plurals: مغاربة mġārba  “Moroccans” (cf. Modern Standard Arabic مغربيين maġrebiyiin “Moroccans”) , تونسة twansa “Tunisians”, فواسة fwāsa “Fessis”, ريافة riyāfa “Riffians”, شلوح šluḥ “Shilha Berbers”, سواسة swāsa “people from the Souss region; frequently used synonymously with Shilha Berbers”, جبالة jbāla “Jbelis”, but مصريين maṣriyiin “Egyptians”, عراقيين erāqiyiin “Iraqis”, etc. It is interesting that Berber too uses complex and apophonic broken plural formations, like other Afro-Asiatic branches: ⴰⵎⵖⵔⵉⴱⵉ amɣribi → ⵉⵎⵖⵔⴰⴱⵉⵢⵏ imɣrabiyen “Moroccans”; ⴰⵛⵍⵃⵉ ašllḥi → ⵉⵛⵍⵃⵉⵢⵏ išlḥiyen “Shilha Berbers”, ⴰⴳⵍⵍⵉⴷ agllid “king” → ⵉⴳⵍⴷⴰⵏ igldan “kings”; ⵜⴰⴳⵍⴷⵉⵜ tagldit kingdom → ⵜⵉⴳⵍⴷⵉⵏ tigldin “kingdoms”. 

The Iranian Presence in Classical Arabic and Medieval Islamic Learning

Written by Afsheen Sharifzadeh, a graduate of Tufts University focusing on Iran and the Caucasus. This article surveys the Iranian presence in pre-Islamic Arabia and the medieval Islamic world and addresses Classical Arabic loans in Modern Persian. It features an exclusive English-language appendix of 200 Middle Iranian loans into Classical Arabic and their etymologies, compiled by the author.

house_of_wisdom_big
A library in present-day Baghdad with the Persian four-ayvān courtyard scheme, named after Bayt al-ikma; courtyard view, Abbasid-era portion.

On the Prevalence of Classical Arabic Loanwords in Modern Persian

Whereas pre-Islamic Iranian languages are virtually free of Semitic vocabulary, Aramaic, Syriac, Hebrew, and Arabic have borrowed a remarkable number lexical items from Iranian (as did late Babylonian, Achaemenid Elamite, Old Armenian, and Georgian). Historical linguists have afforded the majority of these languages comprehensive pedigrees of Iranian borrowings, but regrettably few authors have paid attention to the Iranian loans in the Arabic language and literature, and in doing so, have neglected a rich narrative of cultural contact whereby Persian and Byzantine antecedents formed the creative backbone of early Islamic material and visual culture.

1024px-Sassanian_Empire_621_A.D
The Sassanid Empire (224 A.D.-651 A.D.) was the last Zoroastrian Iranian polity before the arrival of Islam. Sassanian and Byzantine antecedents formed the creative backbone of early Islamic material and visual culture. 

It is no mystery that following the conquest and Islamization of Sassanid Persia throughout the 7th and 8th centuries A.D., Iranian languages were shot through, even to the most far-flung dialects, with Arabic loanwords. Yet Arabic never attained currency as a lingua franca in the Iranian world. Instead, knowledge of the Classical Arabic language throughout the Islamic period was limited to educated city-dwelling Muslim circles, and it was from this stratum of society that Classical Arabic lexica were gradually and purposefully incorporated—often undergoing abstract semantic shifts—into “erudite speech”, which became the basis of New Persian literature, scholarship, and poetry. These Iranian religious figures, literati, linguists, poets, historians, mathematicians, chemists, alchemists, astronomers, physicians, geographers, musicians, and philosophers became preeminent contributors to the canonization of the Arabic language and its transformation from a regional nomadic tongue into a universal vehicle of both doctrinal and secular learning. Acculturation was taking place along the same vector– whereby medieval Islamic architecture, horticulture, cuisine, attire, court culture, political offices, etc. were systematically appropriated from earlier Persian and Byzantine models.

USSR 198355294463
Al-Khwārizmi was an Iranian mathematician, astronomer, and geographer during the Abbasid Caliphate. The English word “algorithm” is his namesake, and the word “algebra” derives from al-jabr, an operation he used to solve quadratic equations. Here he is pictured on a postal stamp issued by the USSR in 1983 (left) and immortalized in statue form at Khiva, Uzbekistan (right).

Knowledge of Classical Arabic was essential and indispensable for religious worship, and the correct reading of the Qur’an was impossible without it. But in the first century of Islamic ascendancy, the Arabs did not produce anything of literary value. If any poetry was composed, it was on the old pagan models and celebrated the poets’ amatory adventures, in stereotyped fashion, rather than the victories of Islam. As Reinhart Dozy notes:

Mais la conversion la plus importante de toute fut celles des Perses. Ce sont eux, et non les Arabes qui ont donné de la fermeté et de la force à l’Islamisme, et en même temps, c’est de leur sein que sont sorties les sectes les plus remarquables. (Dozy, L’Islamisme, p. 156)

It follows that the first grammar of the Arabic language, al-Kitāb (الكتاب), was written by the Persian author Sībūyeh (سيبويه; Arabic: Sībawayh) in the 8th century AD. Many of his Iranian contemporaries with masterful command of Arabic, including Ibn al-Muqaffa’, translated thousands of Indian, Greek, Syriac, and Persian literary works from Middle Persian into Classical Arabic. The epicenter of these intellectual activities was Bayt al-Ḥikma (بيت الحكمة; literally “House of Wisdom”) in Baghdad, which was the Abbasid Caliph al-Ma’mun’s appropriation of the Sassanid Persian Academy of Gundishāpur, the world’s first center of both religious and secular higher-learning. The Caliph had the contents of Gundishāpur and its world-renowned hospital transported en masse to Bayt al-Ḥikma, which was staffed by graduates of the Academy of Gundishāpur and wherein the methods of the older Persian academy were to be emulated. The Bukhtishu-Gundishāpuri family were Nestorian physicians from this university in Persia who served at the Abbasid court through the 7th, 8th, and 9th centuries, spanning six generations. The Caliph al-Mansur’s new capital and crown jewel, Baghdad (“God-Given” in Middle Persian), was no exception to this trend; the city had been modeled on the quintessential Sassanid round city plan (such as at Firuzābād) by a Persian architect and planner, Mashallah ibn Athari, and the astrologically-auspicious location for the imperial city had been chosen by none other than Nawbakht, a Zoroastrian priest. The Abbasid and Fatimid bourgeoisie were patrons of Persian garments, etiquette, court culture, and cuisine, and relied heavily on Persian viziers such as the Barmakid family (برمكيان) to oversee crucial matters pertaining to finance and state administration. As such, they adopted the Sassanid postal system and bureaucratic system (ديوان diwān).

c7 c2alhambra
Persian gardens (top) have influenced the design of gardens from Andalusia to India and beyond. The gardens of the Alhambra show the influence of Persian Garden philosophy and style in a Moorish Palace scale, from the era of Al-Andalus in Spain (bottom). 

Persian influence increased at the Court of the Caliphs, and reached its zenith under al-Ḥādi, Harun al-Rashid, and al-Ma’mun. Most of the ministers of the last were Persians or of Iranian extraction. Afshīn Kheydār b. Kāvūs, the all-powerful favorite of the Caliph al-Mu’tasim and a scion of the Buddhist princes of Osrushana in modern-day Uzbekistan, was appointed Abbasid Supreme General and Governor of Sindh, Jebāl, Libya, Armenia and Azerbaijan. In Baghdad, Persian fashions continued to enjoy an increasing ascendancy, and the old Persian festivals of Nowruz and Mihrigān (origin of the modern Arabic مهرجان mahrajān “festival, celebration”) were celebrated. Persian raiment was the official court dress, and the tall black conical Persian hats (qalansuwa) were already prescribed as official by the second Abbasid caliph in 770 A.D. At the court, the customs of Sassanians were imitated and garments decorated with golden inscription were introduced which it was the exclusive privilege of the ruler to bestow.

The Islamic Golden Age reached its peak during the 10th and 11th centuries, during which Persia was the main theater of academic activity, eclipsing al-Andalus (Muslim Spain) in volume and significance. Persian scholars and polymaths in various fields produced their masterpieces in Arabic—an Arabic whose lexicon they had made applicable to their respective fields in pioneer ways and for which they had popularized new phraseology, word forms, and grammatical structures through the dissemination of their works. Among the most prominent of these individuals were al-Khwārizmi, Abu Sinā (Avicenna), al-Tusi, al-Biruni, Omar Khayyām, al-Haitham, al-Shirāzi, and Nāer Khusraw. Ironically, one can imagine that a rather pure, literary Classical Arabic vernacular was probably in use among Iranian scholarly circles in Khorāsān and Khwārezm (a historic Iranian region roughly corresponding to modern day Uzbekistan and Turkmenistan) during the Abbasid period, while the vernaculars spoken in major Arab-inhabited urban centers around the realm such as Baghdad, Damascus, and Cordoba were of colloquial provenance and were undergoing gradual deviation from Classical pronunciation, grammar and lexicon under the influence of regional linguistic factors. These colloquial transformations are reflected in contemporary literary productions such as 13th century manuscripts of “1001 Nights” (Arabic: الف ليلة و ليلة Alf Leyla wa Leyla, based on an earlier Persian work Hazār Afsāna, literally “1000 Myths”) recovered from Syria and Egypt.

scheherazade
The story of “1001 Nights”, also popularized under an orientalist misnomer “Arabian Nights”, is a series of adapted stories based on a mythical Persian king Shahryār and a storyteller Shahrzādeh. The core characters and structural framework of the Arabic language version are inextricably akin to an earlier Persian work, Hazār Afsāna, with the addition of a few Arabic given names, Abbasid-era stories and motifs such as the Jinn.

This trend did not escape the observation of the 14th century Arab historiographer, Ibn Khaldun, who elaborately explains the primacy of Iranian culture and learning in the nascent Islamic world:

It is a remarkable fact that with few exceptions, most Muslim scholars…in the intellectual sciences have been non-Arabs. Thus the founders of grammar were Sibawayh and after him, al-Farisi and Az-Zajjaj. All of them were of Persian descent…they invented rules of (Arabic) grammar…great jurists were Persians… only the Persians engaged in the task of preserving knowledge and writing systematic scholarly works. Thus the truth of the statement of the Prophet becomes apparent, ‘If learning were suspended in the highest parts of heaven, the Persians would attain it…The intellectual sciences were also the preserve of the Persians, left alone by the Arabs, who did not cultivate them…as was the case with all crafts…This situation continued in the cities as long as the Persians and Persian countries, Iraq, Khorasan and Transoxiana (modern Central Asia), retained their sedentary culture. [Translated by F. Rosenthal (III, pp. 311-15, 271-4 [Arabic]; Frye, R.N. (1977). Golden Age of Persia, London: Weidenfeld & Nicolson, p.91)].

taj-mahal-1
Mughal India, like the Ottoman Empire and the Timurid Empire, was a Persianate society (a society that is either based on, or strongly influenced by the Persian language, culture, literature, art, and/or identity.). Emperor Shāh Jahān (literally “King of the World” in Persian), commissioned a Persian architect from Badakshān named Ustād Ahmad Lāhauri to construct the Tāj Mahal (“Crown Place” in Persian) for his Persian wife and lover, Mumtāz Mahal (née Arjumand Banu Begum.) The Taj Mahal is one of the largest Persian Garden interpretations in the world.

It was via this initially exclusive medium of scholarly and artistic expression promulgated by Muslim Iranian intelligentsia that Middle Persian transformed into New Persian in the urban centers of Khorāsān, Khwārezm and Transoxiana throughout the early Islamic period. Many Middle Persian words were rendered archaic and thence obsolete in favor of abstract Classical Arabic loanwords–a feature that was characteristic of the speech of the Muslim Persian city-dwelling elite. A modified Arabic orthography was applied to this transforming tongue in place of the Pahlavi scripts used to record Middle Persian. This new form of the Persian language became a prestige dialect throughout the Iranian world, spreading from Central Asia throughout the Iranian plateau, and would later enjoy widespread patronage and even official currency in the royal courts of the Ottomans, the Timurids, and the Mughals in India. What are modern-day Turkey and the Indian subcontinent even became important centers of Persian literary and poetic production. In Persianate societies, Arabic words were indirectly transmitted via Persian influence into languages such as Urdu, Turkish, Uzbek, Azerbaijani, Kurdish, Turkmen, Pashto, Uyghur, as evidenced by the retention of Persian phonological modifications to Classical Arabic pronunciation in these languages. Sarti Uzbek (but not Khorezmian or Kipchak Uzbek) even lost vowel harmony—a rudimentary feature of Turkic phonology—as a result of Persian substratum and bilingualism.

But this was by no means the first golden age for the Persian language—pre-Islamic Iranian languages likewise exerted a remarkably pervasive influence on neighboring tongues under the aegis of Iranian suzerains and civilized elite in those territories. Classical Armenian contained an impressive sixty percent of its general vocabulary derived from Iranian languages, and most Aramaic languages had been heavily Persified by the time of the Islamic conquest—even serving as media of transmission for Iranian borrowings into Arabic.

486e2d09a6dApaxT 631fc995ad Khanaka (Sufi monastery) of Nadir Divan-Beghi {1620}, Bukhara09-Bukhara-2013raw1640b registan-v-samarkandeshahi-zinda-samarkand022_Klub_puteshestviy_Pavla_Aksenova_Uzbekistan_Samarkand_Registan_Medrese_Sherdor_Foto_efesenko_-_Depositphotos-1024x623
[From top, left-right: 1. Chahār Minār, Bukhara  2. Bukhara, view of old city and wall  3. Nādir Divan-Begi Khānaqāh, a Sufi monastery featuring depictions of Simurgh from Ferdowsi’s Shāhnāmeh on its pishtaq, Bukhara  4. Bālā-Hauz, Bukhara  5. Gūr-i Amīr, Tamerlane’s mausoleum, Samarqand  6. Rēgistān square, Samarqand  7. Shāh-i Zinda, Samarqand  8. Shērdār Madrasa at Rēgistān, Samarqand]
Bukhara and Samarqand are still natively Persian-speaking (Tajik) cities in modern-day Uzbekistan; the former traditionally boasted a sizable Persophone Jewish element as well that has since relocated to Israel. The structures depicted are architectural heirlooms to the region’s robust Persianate past and former economic prosperity under the Samanid, Ghaznavid, and later Timurid empires. From a philological standpoint, we can imagine that it was in urban centers like these that incoming Turcophone groups interacted with the autochthonous settled Persian-speaking populations in Transoxiana, in turn giving rise to the modern Uzbek yoke, and wherein the Uzbek language (Sart dialect; progenitor of the modern literary language) gradually lost features typical of Turkic—notably the vowels /ü/, /ö/ and vowel harmony—and adopted thousands of Persian words and phrases. (*note the Khorezmian Uzbek language is of Oghuz provenance but features a heavy admixture of Uyghur-Uzbek elements; the Kipchak Uzbek language is closely related to Kazakh. Both of these languages are vowel-harmonized and feature relatively fewer Persianisms in their lexicon and morphology) 

Thus the prevalence of Classical Arabic loanwords in New Persian is largely the fruit of a medieval scholarly tendency among Iranian intelligentsia who composed their works in Classical Arabic to then incorporate Arabic words and phrases into their speech, perhaps in an attempt to “enrich” the non-Islamic Middle Persian tongue and thereby emphasize their elevated stratum in society (city-dwelling, educated Muslim families) on the basis of their prestigious vernacular. Iranian scholars and polymaths also played a pivotal role in the standardization and diffusion of Classical Arabic, and Persians, Greeks and Syriacs served as cultural brokers in the Abbasid court. 

Persian Islamic Scholars Composed All Six of the Major Sunni Hadith Collections (al-Kutub as-Sittah

During the 9th century, all of the six canonical collections of the Sunni ḥadith, venerated by Sunni Muslims as al-Kutub as-Sittah (الكتب الستة) and second in importance only to the Quran, were composed by Persian authors. Their names and places of origin are listed below:

1. Sahih Bukhari, collected by Imam Bukhari (d. 256 AH, 870 CE), born in Bukhārā
2. Sahih Muslim, collected by Muslim b. al-Hajjaj (d. 261 AH, 875 CE), born in Nishāpur, Khorāsān
3. Sunan al-Sughra, collected by al-Nasa’i (d. 303 AH, 915 CE), born in Nisā, Khorāsān
4. Sunan Abu Dawood, collected by Abu Dawood (d. 275 AH, 888 CE), born in Sistān
5. Jami al-Tirmidhi, collected by al-Tirmidhi (d. 279 AH, 892 CE), born in Termez, Khorāsān
6. Either:
Sunan ibn Majah, collected by Ibn Majah (d. 273 AH, 887 CE), born in Qazvīn
Sunan ad-Dārimī , collected by Imam Al-Darimi (181H–255H), born in Samarqand

List of Middle Iranian Loanwords in Classical Arabic (Compiled by the Afsheen Sharifzadeh)

Ahmad Amin writes “at a glance one can see that the Arabs in every point or every way they turned or for every necessity of life were obliged to use Persian words. Besides the words themselves they adopted the phrase-making ideas and expressions used by the Persians in explaining various matters or in defining things.”

Hundreds of Iranian words and terms began to enter into Arabic language, sometimes via an Aramaic milieu, and were Arabicized (تعريب ta’rīb) in eccentric ways according to the phonetic and morphological system of that language. Verb derivatives were even formed from Iranian nouns according to the Arabic patterns (اوزان awzān). It follows that Iranian lexical borrowings in Classical Arabic (معربات mu’arrabāt) pertained to all domains of civilized society, including botany, culinary matters, administration, architecture, minerals, philosophy, zoology, musical instruments, and items of luxury and power adopted from Sassanian Persia. The following are some notable and readily-recognizable Eastern Iranian/Parthian, Middle Persian (MP) loans, and Early New Persian (NP) that remain in Modern Standard Arabic (اللغة العربية الفصحى) as well as most dialects, although borrowings in Classical Arabic and Mesopotamian/Gulf dialects are more varied and numerous.

LIST


abad- eternity (MP: a-pād “without foot, endless”)

‘abqari- genius, highest perfection, unsurpassed (MP: abargar “superior, highest”)

adab– literature; courtesy, civility (constructed from MP: dab)

‘anbar- ambergris (MP: hambar)

anbār– warehouse, depot (MP: hambār)

argīla– waterpipe (NP: nārgīl “coconut”)

‘askar, ‘askari- army, military (constructed from MP: lashkar)

‘ar, ‘aar, mu’aar– perfume, perfumist (constructed from MP: atr)

azraq, zarqā’- yellow (constructed from MP: zargōn “golden”)

Baghdād (MP: baga+data “Given by God”)

bahlawān- clown, gymnast (MP: pahlawān “champion”)

bakht- luck (from MP: bakht)

banafsaj- purple, violet (MP: wanafshag, NP: banafsha)

bandar– port, harbor (MP: bandar)

baqshish- tip, gratuity (MP: bakhshish “gratuity”)

bāriz, baraza– prominent; to elevate (constructed from MP, Parthian: borz “high; elevate”)

barīd– post, mailing (constructed from MP: burida-dum “a docked mule appointed for the conveyance of messengers”)

barnāmaj- program (MP: abarnāmag)

bas- (coll.) but, enough, stop (NP: bas)

bashkīr– hand towel (MP: pēshgir)

bathinjān- eggplant (MP: bādengān)

ba duck (MP: bat)

bayān- statement, report, accouncement (MP: payām)

baydaq– a footman [in chess] (constructed from MP: payādag, NP: piyāda)

bulbul- bird (MP: bulbul)

bulūr- crystal (MP: bolur)

bunduq– hazelnut (MP: pondik)

bunj- anaesthetic (MP: pōng)

burj– tower (MP: burg)

burwāz- frame (MP: parwast “enclosure”)

bustān- garden (MP: bostān)

bāmiya- okra (MP: bamiya)

bārija- battleship, flagship (MP: bārūja “flower pot”< “a deep-hulled vessel”)

bāzār– market (Parthian: wahāchār, MP: wāzār, NP: bāzār)

būsa- kiss (MP: bōs)

dabīr, dabbara- manager; to oversee, plot (constructed from MP: dipīr)

daftar- notebook, office (MP: dabtar)

darb- gate (MP: darpân “gatekeeper”, Arabic reflex of this term)

darwīsh- ascetic, particularly Sufi (MP: dreyosh “one who lives in holy indigence”)

dashin, yadshin– dedicate (constructed from MP: dashn “gift”)

dumbek– drum (MP: tumbag)

dukkān– shop (MP: dukan)

dulāb– wheel (MP: dol-ab “water wheel [machine]”)

dunyā- world (MP: dunya)

dustūr- constitution (MP: dastwar, NP: dastūr)

dīn, diāna, tadayyun- religion, piety (constructed from MP: dēn> OP: daēna)

dīnār– unit of currency (MP: denār)

dīwān- high governmental body, council (MP: dēwān “archive”)

falak- orb, sphere (MP: parak “the star Canopus, brightest star”)

Fārsī, Bilād al-Furus– Persian, Persia (MP: Pārsīg)

fattash, taftīsh, mufattish- inspect (constructed from MP: pitakhsh “viceroy”>p-t-kh-sh>f-t-sh)

fayj– courier (MP: payg, NP: payk)

fayrūz- turquoise (MP: pērōzag, NP: firuza)

fihris, fahrasa- index, register (constructed from MP: pahrist)

finjān- cup (MP: pengân)

firdaws- paradise (MP: pardēs)

fifia- alfalfa (MP: ispist)

fustuq- pistacchio (MP: pistag)

fīl- elephant (MP: pil)

filfil– pepper (MP: pelpel)

fūlādh– steel (MP: polad)

a- towel (MP: pusha)

handasa, muhandis- engineer (constructed from MP: [h]andāzag “measure, quantity”, NP: andāza)

hawā’- air, atmosphere (MP: havā> OP: hvayāv “good current”)

haykal- framework, outline (MP: paykar)

Hind- India (Persian name for Sindh, product of h>s Iranian/Indo-Aryan isogloss)

hindām– symmetry (MP: [h]andām “symmetry, arrangment”)

ibrīq- jug (MP: abrēk)

īwān- a chamber or vault, often at the exterior entrance of a building (MP: aywān)

jāmūs– buffalo (MP: gāwmēsh)

janzīr– chain (MP: zanjīr)

ja, jaās- gypsum; plasterer (MP: gach)

jawhar- essence, substance (constructed from MP: gōhr)

jawhara, jawahir- jewel (constructed from MP: gōhr)

jawz- walnut (MP: gōz)

jazar– carrot (MP: gazar; descendents Larestani: gazrak, Armenian: gazar))

jund, jundīyya, tajannud, tajnīd- army, military service, enlistment (constructed from MP: gund “army”)

jāsūs, tajassus- spy, espionage (constructed from MP: goshash>g-sh-sh>j-s-s, “hearer, listener”)

julnār- pomegranate blossom (MP: gulnār)

jūrāb- socks (NP: jawrāb)

ka’ak– a type of pastry (MP: kāk)

kabāb, kubba- roasted meat on skewers (MP: kabāb)

kahrabā’- electricity (MP: kāhrubā, “yellow amber”)

kamān, kamānja- a musical instrument (MP: kamān “bow”, kamāncha “little bow”)

kānūn- campfire, furnace (MP: kānun)

kanz- treasure (MP: ganj>OP: ganza)

khām- raw [materials], ore (MP: khām “raw, crude”)

khandaq- moat, pit (MP: kandag)

khanjar- dagger (MP: khōngar)

kharj, kharrāj– tribute, duty, work (constructed from MP: harg)

khiār- cucumber (MP: khyār)

khurda- scraps, fragments (MP: khurdag)

khammana, takhmin- guess, speculate, value (constructed from MP: gumān g-m-n > kh-m-n)

khān- shelter, rest stop (MP: khān “house”)

khashin, khushūna- rough, harsh; severity (constructed from MP: khashen)

khazīna, makhzan- treasury (constructed from MP: ganjēna g-j-n > kh-z-n)

kīmīā’– chemistry (MP: kimiā)

kīs- bag (MP: kisag)

kisra- idol (from MP: Kasra, Khosrow)

kūz- vase, storage vessel (MP: kōz)

laymūn: lemon (MP: lēmōg)

lāzaward: lapis lazuli (MP: lajward)

lubiya- bean (MP: lobiya)

mahara, muhr- stamp, seal (MP: muhr)

mahrajān- festival (MP: Mihrigân, Zoroastrian autumnal equinox celebration)

al-Māristān– premier hospital complex of Abbasid-era Baghdad (from MP: wēmāristān; NP: bimārestān)

marj – field (Parthian: marg, MP: marv)

marjān- pearl, coral (MP: margān)

mās– diamond (MP: almās)

masaka, massaka, amsaka, tamassak– adhere, stick, cling, take hold (constructed from MP: mashk “musk”)

mask– musk (MP: mashk)

mawz– banana (MP: mōz)

maydān- city square, field (MP: mēdān)

mezza– taste, starter (MP: mizag, NP: mazza)

mihrāb- niche in the wall of mosque indicating the qibla or direction of Mecca (MP: Mihrāba “Mithraeum”)

miswāk– toothpick, toothbrush (constructed from MP: sawāk, from MP sūdan “to rub, scrape”)

muzarkash, zarkash- colorful, decorated (constructed from MP: zarkesh “gilded”)

nabāt- sugar crystals, “sugar candy” (MP: nabat)

nabīdh– wine (MP: nabēd)

nadhar, intidhār, munādhir, mandhūr– to look, watch, wait (constructed from MP: negar, negaristan)

nafoil, petroleum (MP: naft)

namr- cushion, pillow (Parthian: namr “meek”, NP: narm)

naqsh, munāqasha, niqqāsh, naqqāshi, manqūsh- painter, artist (constructed from MP: nakhsh)

narjis- narcissus flower (MP: nargis)

nasrīn- sweetbriar flower (MP: nasrēn)

nishān- badge (MP: nishan)

numūdhaj- exemplary (MP: namudag)

nākhudhā- ship captain (MP: nāv-khudā)

nāranj: orange, clementine (MP: narang)

nāy: reed flute (MP: nay)

nīlūfar: nenuphar, lotus, water lily (MP: nilōpal)

qabr- grave, coffin (MP: gabr “hollow, cavity”)

qafa– cage (MP: kafas)

qahramān- champion (MP: kār-framān, “manager, overseer”)

qas’a- serving pot (MP: kāsa)

Qazwīn- Caspian (MP: Kasbīn)

qirmiz– crimson, scarlet (MP: kermest)

qubba- vault, dome, cupola (MP: gunbad)

qumbula- bomb (MP: kumpula)

raālead, tin (constructed from MP: arziz > Parth: archich)

rizq, razaqa, istarzaqa, rezzāq- daily wage, sustenance; to bestow or endow (constructed from MP: rōzig, Parthian: rōchik “daily bread”)

aidala, aidaliyya– pharmacy (constructed from MP: chandal “sandalwood”)

aqr- hawk (MP: chark)

alīb- cross (MP: chalipa)

andal- sandals, sandalwood (MP: chandal “sandalwood”)

andūq– chest, crate; treasurer’s office (MP: sandūk)

anj– harp (MP: chang)

sarādiq- pavillion, canopy (MP: srādag)

sardāb- basement (MP: sardāba)

sarīr- throne, bed (MP: sarir)

sawsan– lily (MP: sōsan)

shakush- hammer (MP: chakuch)

shāhīn- falcon (MP: shāhēn)

shatranj- chess (MP: chatrang)

shā’ib, shā’ibа, ashīb – grizzly (constructed from MP: āshub)

shāwīsh– sergeant (MP: chāwush “seargent, herald; the leader of a caravan”)

shāy- tea (MP: chāy)

shibbith– dill (MP: sheved)

shīsha- waterpipe (NP: shīshag “bottle, flask”)

siāl, sayl, musīl– flowing, runny (constructed from MP: sayl, i.e. saylāb)

sifir- zero (MP: zifr)

simsār, samsara- middleman, broker (MP: samsar)

sirāj- lamp, light (MP: chirāgh)

sirā– path, way, custom (MP: srat, “street”)

sirdāb- tunnel, cellar (MP: sardāb)

sirwāl- pants, trousers (MP: shalwār)

sufra- dining table (MP: supra)

sukkar- sugar (MP: shakar)

Aīn- China (MP Chin, name for China, from the Qin dynasty)

sādej- plain, simple (MP: sādag)

sīkh- skewer (MP: sikh)

īnīyya- tray (MP: chini, in reference to imported chinaware from the East)

sīra: juice (MP: shirag)

abaq- plate, dish (MP: tābag “frying pan”)

ābūr- line, queue (MP: tabur)

arāz- type, brand (MP: taraz)

arbūsha– a type of hat, “red fez” hat (NP: sar “head” + pūsh “wear”)

takht, takhta- platform, bench (MP: takht “throne”)

tanbal- lazy (MP: tanparvar)

tannūr- oven (MP: tanūr)

tannūra- skirt, dress (MP:tanvar)

tarjuma, mutarjim– translation (constructed from MP: targumān)

tarzī- tailor (MP: darzi)

tāj- crown (MP>Parthian: tāg)

āzej– fresh, new (MP: tāzag)

tūt- mulberry, berry (MP: tut)

ustuwāna- disc, cylinder (NP: ostovāna)

ustādh- teacher, master (NP ostād>MP: avistād “master, skillfull man”)

waqt- time (from Parthian, Eastern M.Irn: bakht)

ward, warda- flower, rose (Parthian: ward, Early MP: varda> OP: varda)

wazīr, wizāra- vizier (MP: vichira “bureaucrat, member of Sassanian court”)

yasmīn- jasmine (MP: yasmēn)

yāqūt- ruby (MP: yākand)

Yūnān- Greece (MP: Yonan, Persian name for Ionia)

za’farān– saffron (MP: zarparōn)

zaman, zamān- time [abstract] (MP: zamān, zamanāg, Parthian: zhamān, zhamānak)

zandīq- heretic (MP: zandik)

zanjabīl- ginger (MP: singibir)

zayt, zaytūn– olive (MP: zayt)

zilzāl- earthquake (MP: zilzilag)

zinzāna- prison, dungeon (MP: zindānag)

zumurrud– emerald (MP: uzumburd)


Persian Factors in pre-Islamic Arabia and the days of the Prophet Muhammad

The contacts between Arabia and the Sassanian Persian Empire were very close in the period immediately preceding Islam. The Arab Kingdom centered at al-Hira on the Euphrates had long been under Persian influence and was a headquarters for the diffusion of Iranian culture among the Arabs. Throughout the titanic struggle between the Sassanids and the Byzantine Empire, where al-Hira had been set against the Kingdom of Ghassan, other Arab tribes became involved in the conflict and naturally came under the cultural influence of Persia. The Court of the Lakhmids at al-Hira was in pre-Islamic times a famous center of literary activity, and Christian poets such as Adi ibn Zaid lived long at this court and produced poems containing extensive Persian loanwords. But the Iranian influence was not merely felt along the Mesopotamian areas; it was an Iranian general and Iranian influence that overthrew the Abyssinian suzerainty in southern Arabia during Muhammad’s lifetime.

640px-Kamal-ud-din_Bihzad_001
A Persian manuscript from the 15th century describing the construction of Al-Khornaq castle In Al-Hira, the Arab Lakhmids’ capital city. The Lakhmids were a Christian Arab tribe of Yemenite stock who established their center in southern Iraq in 266 A.D., near the Sassanid capital of Seleucia-Ctesiphon.

In the early days of the Prophet’s mission, there were only seventeen men in the tribe of Quraysh who could read or write. It is said that an Iranian man, known as Hammad ar-Rawiya, seeing how little the Arabs cared for poetry and literature, urged them to study poems. In fact it was Hammad who selected the Mu’allaqāt, the seven Arabic poems written in pre-Mohammedan times and inscribed in gold on rolls of coptic cloth and hung up on the curtains covering the Ka’aba. In this period, Hammad knew more than any one else about the Arabic poetry. According to Edward Browne, before the advent of Islam, the Arabs had a negligible literature and scant poetry. It was the Iranians who after their conversion to Islam, feeling the need to learn the language of the Qur’an, began to use that language for other purposes.

Ph. Gignoux hypothesizes that the Quranic phrase bismi’llahi’l-rahmani’l-rahim was modeled on the Middle Persian pad nam-i yazdan. Although there were antecedent Jewish and Christian parallels, a similar formula was also current among Zoroastrians and Manichaeans.

In The Vocabulary of the Quran, Arthur Jeffrey enumerates over 40 words of Iranian origin in Qur’an, among them the following: ebriq, estabraq, barzakh, burhan, tanur, jizya, junah (from gonah), dirham, din, dinar, rezq, rauza, zabania, zarabi, zakat, zanjabil, zur, sejjil, seraj, soradaq, serbal, sard and zard, sondos, suq, salaba, ‘abqari, efrit, forat, firdaus, fil, kafur, kanz, maeda, al majus, marjan, mask, nuskha, harut and marut, wareda, wazir, yaqut.

In addition, many terms in Classical Arabic literature are transliterations or calques of the Persian: Khamsa Mustaraqa from Panjeh-ye DozdidehMushahira from MahianehNisf an-Nahar from Nim-ruzan-Namal al-fares from Murcheh-SavariMaleeh (origin of Levantine Arabic mniih “good, well”) from NamakinBeyt an-Nar from AteshkadehBalut al-Moluk from Shah-balutSamm al-Himar from Khar-zahrehLisan al-thawr from Gav-zabanReyhan al-Mulk from Shah-Esperam.

Conclusion:

The exchange, then, ran through a single class of men. The Iranian man of letters who ornamented his Persian with the vocabulary of the Quran to mark his faith and his station was the same who wrote Arabic’s first grammar, compiled its canonical traditions, staffed its bureaus and its hospitals, and filled its lexicon with the words of the court, the garden and the bazaar; and each language emerged from his hands wearing the other’s ornaments. Arabic gave Persian the terms of its new religion and the abstractions of its sciences; Persian gave Arabic the furniture of civilized life. Neither loan was levied; both were freely contracted, and by the same borrowers. It is a rare thing in the history of languages for two tongues to owe each other so much; it is rarer still that the debts on both sides should have been incurred by the same hands.

Sources: 

Eilers, Wilhelm. Iranisches Lehngut im arabischen Lexikon: Über einige Berufsnamen und Titel. Gravenhage: Mouton, 1962.

Lane, Edward William. An Arabic-English Lexicon.
http://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/text?doc=Perseus%3Atext%3A2002.02.0021%3Aroot%3Dxmn

Hovannisian, RIchard G.; Sabagh, Georges. The Persian Presence in the Islamic World. Cambridge University Press, 1988.

Tafazzoli, A. Arabic Language ii. Iranian loanwords in Arabic.
http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/arabic-ii.

Browne, Edward. A Literary History of Persia, Vol. I. 

MacKenzie, D.N. A Concise Pahlavi Dictionary. Psychology Press, 1971.

Shir, Addi. Al-Alfâz Al-Fârsîyya Al-Mu`arraba (A Dictionary of Persian Words in the Arabic Language). Library of Lebanon, 1980.

Gharib, B. Sogdian Language i. Loanwords in Persian.
http://www.iranicaonline.org/articles/sodgian-language-i-loanwords

Agius, Dionisius A. Classic Ships of Islam: From Mesopotamia to the Indian Ocean. Brill Academic Pub, 2007.

Cheung, Johnny. Etymological Dictionary of the Iranian Verb. Brill Academic Pub, 2007.

علي الثويني. التائه بين التأثيرات اللسانية و عقدة الخواجة 2-9/محمد مندلاوي
http://www.hekar.net/modules.php?name=News&file=print&sid=8603

تاثیر زبان فارسی بر زبان و ادبیات شبه قاره هند. محمد عجم.
http://www.hozehonari.com/PrintListItem.aspx?id=22896

Arabic Dialectics Series: Muslim Baghdadi Arabic

Written by Afsheen Sharifzadeh, a graduate of Tufts University focusing on Iran and the Caucasus. This brief survey of Muslim Baghdadi Arabic is intended for intermediate and advanced students of Modern Standard Arabic (MSA) who seek a linguistic introduction to the Baghdadi dialect by comparison to MSA and Mashriqī dialects.

1681px-Arabic_Dialects.svg
Arabic dialect families. Dark green denotes Mesopotamian Arabic and yellow denotes North Mesopotamian Arabic. Note Mesopotamian Arabic dialects are also spoken in a few pockets in eastern Iran (Khorasan) and Central Asia (Uzbekistan and Tajikistan). 

The colloquial Arabic varieties of Iraq belong to two main dialect groups: Mesopotamian Arabic also known as the gilit-group (Baghdad, Basra, Central Asian Arabic, Khuzestani and Khorasani Arabic in Iran), and North Mesopotamian Arabic or the qeltugroup (spoken in Mosul, eastern Syria, and by Jewish and Christian Iraqis and Anatolian Arabs). In linguistics, the gilit-qeltu paradigm is based on the different phonological systems characterizing the two dialect groups, which can be observed in the form of the word “I said”—Baghdad: gilit; Mosul: qeltu.

Muslim Baghdadi Arabic, belonging to the gilit-group, is the prestige dialect of the country. In this article, the term “Muslim” is used to distinguish the dialect from Jewish Baghdadi Arabic, a qeltu-group dialect that was spoken by almost one-third of Baghdad’s inhabitants until 1948, and is currently only spoken in Israel and abroad where it faces imminent extinction among the diaspora. Iraq is also home to a number of other languages, including Kurdish languages (Sorani, Kurmanji or Bahdini, Gorani, Zazaki), Neo-Aramaic and Neo-Mandaic, Turkoman (South Azeri), Armenian, and Persian.

iraq_languages_map
Language composition of Iraq

Muslim Baghdadi Arabic is a dialect of Bedouin provenance that features several unique phonetic, lexical, and morphological paradigms vis-à-vis the surrounding Mashriqī sedentary dialects, and is layered with influences from urban Medieval Baghdadi Arabic and foreign languages such as Turkish, Persian, Kurdish, and Aramaic. This dialect, which belongs to the so-called gilit-group, should not be confused with the Iraqi dialects of the qeltu-group (Jewish Baghdadi Arabic, Christian Baghdadi Arabic, and North Mesopotamian Arabic), all of which seem to be direct descendants of Medieval Baghdadi Arabic—a sedentary medieval dialect. The qeltu-group dialects have different sound systems and morphologies from Muslim Baghdadi and also seem to have retained a greater volume of foreign loanwords that have been more vigorously uprooted from the Muslim dialect under the Ba’ath regime.

Figure 1: Mashriqī Dialect Comparison Table prepared by the author; differences between Standard, Maslāwi, Baghdādi, Damascene (Levantine) and Cairene (Egyptian) dialects. Prepared by Afsheen Sharifzadeh

EnglishStandard Arabic (MSA)Mosul, Baghdad (Jewish and Christian)Baghdad (Muslim)DamascusCairo
“I told you (f.)”Ana qultu lakiAna qeltolkiĀni gilitlichAna ‘eltellikAna ‘oltilik
“A lot, many, very”Kathīr, KathīranKsīɣHwāye, KullishKtīr‘Awī, Ktīr
“I want”UrīduAɣīdArīdBiddīʕāyiz(a)
“She had”Kān ʕandahaKān ʕandaChān ʕedhaKān ʕendaKān ʕandáha
“I didn’t do”Lam afʕalMa suwwetuMa sawweytMa ʕameletMa ʕameltesh
“With them”MaʕhumMaʕhemWiyyāhumMaʕunWayyáhum
“How are you (f.)?”Kayfa Hāluki?Ashlōnki?Shlōnich?Kīfik?Izzáyik?
“There exists”Hunāk, HunālikaAkūAkū
“What”MādhaAshūShinūShūEh
“Here”HonāHunīHnāneHōnHéna
“Now”Al’ānHessaHessaHallā’Dilwa’tī
“This way, like this”HākadhāHēkīHīchīHēkēKeda
“They were going”Kānū yadhhabūKānū yiɣūhūChānow da-yerhūnKānu ʕam-birūhūKānū  birūhū


Phonemic characteristics

1.) Qāf ق is pronounced differently depending on the word. Sometimes this may seem arbitrary, but there is historical and phonemic rationalization for it. For example, in words that denote higher or abstract concepts, the Classical pronunciation of the qāf has been retained, such as the in the words حقيقةHaqīqa “truth”, مستقبل mustaqbil“future”, and اقتصاد IqtiSād “economy”. The archaic uvular pronunciation of qaaf is also retained in borrowings from Medieval Baghdadi Arabic: دقيقة daqīqaminute, moment”, قرأ qira “he read”.

2.) In general in quotidian/mundane words of Arabic origin, there is a Bedouinization of the qāf from “q” –> “g”. For example, “I say” اقول is pronounced agūl, “I arose/began” قمت is pronounced gumit, “heart” قلب is pronounced gaLub (the “L” is emphatic), and “moon” قمر is pronounced gumar. There is also a tendency to retain the “g” phoneme in loanwords and in some instances to evolve in favor of it (i.e. khāshūga“spoon”, from Persian قاشق qāshogh). However as mentioned above, lexical borrowings from Medieval Baghdadi Arabic regardless of usage retain the Classical uvular pronunciation of qāf.

3.) In some very specific instances, the classical qāf sound is realized as “k” (q–>k). This phenomenon is observed in only a handful of words and seems to be rooted in voiced/unvoiced consonant agreement. For example, the word “time” وقت can be pronounced wakit or alternatively waqit. However, in the fixed word شوكت shwakit(“when”), only the former form is used. We also see this sound change in the 3rd person simple past of the verb “to kill” قتل, which can be heard as kital.

These pronunciations are by and large not interchangeable, and in fact switching between the “q” and “g” phonemes can result in change of meaning (i.e. farraq “to divide” and farrag“to distribute”; warga “leaf” and warqa “piece of paper”). Thus the pronunciation of qaaf depends on the word. Also as a note, the Levantine and Egyptian pronunciation of qāfق as hamza ء is not found in any Mesopotamian dialects.

The letter Dādض is always pronounced as Dhā’ظ, and Dhā’ is in turn pronounced as its classical voiced alveolar fricative pronunciation (as in Modern Standard Arabic).

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PKcQGWXzvAE
Iraqi Assyrian singer Daly performs song in different languages and dialects of Iraq in this order: Muslim Baghdadi Arabic, Kurmanji (Bahdini) Kurdish, Assyrian Neo-Aramaic, Muslim Baghdadi Arabic, Muslim Baghdadi Arabic, Basrawi Arabic, Basrawi Arabic.


Lexicon

Muslim Baghdadi Arabic is by no means a creole language, despite its lexical and grammatical distinctions. In fact these differences are not nearly as anomolous as features of other dialects in the Mesopotamian and North Mesopotamian groups, such as Anatolian Arabic and Khorasani Arabic. The core vocabulary of Muslim Baghdadi Arabic derives from Classical Arabic, Medieval Baghdadi Arabic, and Bedouin dialects. For a comparison of Muslim Baghdadi lexicon with other Mashriqī dialects, see Figure 1 above.

There are, however, many loanwords from peripheral languages and other areal features that have made their way into common speech via foreign hegemony, historic trade relations, bilingualism and direct contact between groups living in Baghdad. Many loanwords have become obsolete or consciously uprooted from the language, particularly within the last century. 

EnglishPersianStandard ArabicMuslim BaghdadiDamascene Arabic
“Also, too”Ham, nīzAydhanHam, hammenaKamān
“By foot”Piyādeʕala al-AqdāmPyādaMashī
“Wheel”CharkhDūlāb (from Middle Persian)CharikhDūlāb
“Manly, Womanly”Mardāne, ZanāneRujūlī, NiswīMardāna, ZanānaRujūlī, Niswī
“Good”Khōsh, KhūbJayyidKhōsh, Zein, HelūMnīh, Helū
“Cure, remedy”ChāreʕilājChāraʕilāj

Figure 2: Language comparison tables prepared by the author; some Persian words in Muslim Baghdadi Arabic. Prepared by Afsheen Sharifzadeh

EnglishOttoman TurkishStandard ArabicMuslim BaghdadiDamascene Arabic
“Slow”YavashBaTi’Yawāsh (borrowed via Persian)Shwayye
“Impolite, mannerless”EdebsizGheir mu’addabAdabsizz‘Alīl adab
“Ice cream”DondurmaBūdhaDondirmaBūza
“My lord” (archaic)AghamSayyidīĀghātīSayyidī
“Maybe, hopefully”BelkiYumkinBalkīYimkin

Figure 3: Language comparison tables prepared by the author; some Turkish words in Muslim Baghdadi Arabic. Prepared by Afsheen Sharifzadeh

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h3pMiwvfa5U
RT Arabic interview (part 1) with Tamara al-Daghestani, speaking in Muslim Baghdadi Arabic, while the interviewer speaks in Standard Arabic. Tamara’s family descends from warriors who were brought to Iraq from Daghestan in modern-day Russia.

Grammatical Distinctions

1.) The present progressive tense is formed by adding the prefix da- to the conjugated stem of the verb. This is likely a borrowing and adaptation from Persian into the early Abbasid-era Baghdadi vernacular. For example, “I am listening” is pronounced Ani da-asmaʕ, and “I am laughing” is Ani da-adhHak.

2.) The particle of existence as in “there is/there are” is akū and “there is not/there are not” is mā. The origin of this word is believed to be from the southeastern Babylonian Aramaic that was spoken in central Mesopotamia prior to the Arab invasion (for further reading, see author Christa Muller-Kessler).

3.) The existence of an indeterminate indefinite article fad فد (“a, some”) that precedes the noun it describes is highly unusual and unique to Mesopotamian Arabic (i.e. “fad rijjāl, fad imreyye” = “a man, a woman”). This likely developed from the use of the Classical word fardفرد meaning “one, single (thing)” in colloquial Medieval Baghdadi Arabic (although it would have been pronounced with guttural “r” as in French and Modern Hebrew according to the sound system of that dialect, which provides insight to the development of its modern pronunciation), which is itself probably a grammatical influence from Persian or Aramaic via substrate/superstrate or bilingualism.

4.) The use of the proclitic d(i)-to add a note of impatience to an imperative verb. The role of this marker is just to intensify the sense of imperative (duklū= “eat!”, digʕud = “sit!”, digūm= “get up!”). This was originally a feature of Medieval Baghdadi Arabic.

5.) The word gām as an indicator of the future or “to begin to do something”, which is based on the Aramaic word qa’em formerly employed in Mandaic and Talmudic Aramaic.

6.) The Classical feminine 2nd and 3rd person plural pronouns are retained and exist as intan and hinna and their suffix pronouns are -chan and -hin respectively. This marked retention of feminine plurals is highly unusual among Mashriqī sedentray dialects and can be attributed to the dialect’s Bedouin origin.

7.) Sometimes colloquially there is an omission of the future tense altogether (an influence from Persian). For example “I will come with you” can be expressed Āni ajī wiyyāk.

8.) Muslim Baghdadi Arabic has consonant harmony, which is essentially the ability of certain consonants (emphatic consonant, bilabials, and velars) to affect or “color” the quality of the vowel they occur directly next to. For example, gumar <— Classical قمر qamar (“moon”) ; buSal <— Classical بصل baSal (“onion”); sima <— Classical سماء samā(“sky”).

It is important to note that all lexical and syntactical features of Aramaic origin have reached Muslim Baghdadi Arabic through the medium of Medieval Baghdadi Arabic, rather than direct contact, because that would be inconsistent with the historical development of Muslim Baghdadi Arabic both chronologically and socio-culturally and would not align correctly with the “life span” of those Aramaic dialects.


Another point of interest is the affrication of Kāك to “ch” (k–>ch), which is a Bedouin feature. This occurs again mostly in quotidian words or lexical borrowings from Persian and Turkish. For example, the past tense of the verb “to be” كان kāna is conjugated as follows:

EnglishModern Standard ArabicMuslim Baghdadi
“I was”Ana kuntuĀni chinit
“You (m.) were”Anta kuntaInta chinit
“You (f.) were”Anti kuntiInti chinti
“He was”Huwa kānHuwwa chān
“She was”Hiya kānatHiyya chānat
“We were”Nahnū kunnaEhna chinna
“You (pl.) were”Antum kuntumIntū chintū
“They were”Hum kānūHumma chānōw

Figure 4: past tense of  كان kāna in Muslim Baghdadi

In quotidian words of Arabic origin, the “ch” pronunciation is favored over “k”, although there is incidence of both:

kalbكلب —-> chalib (“dog”)

shubbākشباك —-> shubbāch (“window”)

kabīrكبير —-> chibīr(“big, large”)

bakāبكاء —-> bachī(“cry, weep”)

sikkīnسكّين —-> sichchīna(“knife”)

kidhdhābكذاب —-> chedhdhāb (“lier”)


In lexical borrowings:

chakūch = “hammer” (from Persian via Turkish)

-chī= archaic occupational suffix, as in qundarchī“shoemaker” (from Persian via Turkish)

charpāya= “bed, stand” (from Persian)

chakmak = “boots” (from Persian)

chāi = “tea” (from Persian)

pācha = a traditional dish consisting of sheep’s head and hooves (from Persian)

In some instances, foreign lexical borrowings have adopted the “ch” sound when they originally lacked it: chafchīr = “spatula, large pouring spoon” (from Persian kafgīr)

The k–>ch sound change also serves an important morphological purpose–namely, to distinguish between masculine and feminine object suffixes. The masculine form is -k while the feminine form is -ch. Ex:

Akhūk= Your (m.) brother

Akhūch= Your (f.) brother

Wiyyāk = with you (m.)

Wiyyāch = with you (f.)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Shm4fRNo3M0
“Good Morning Arabs” interview with Iraqi poet, Shahad Shammari, speaking Muslim Baghdadi Arabic while the interviewer speaks Emirati Arabic.

The non-Arabic phoneme “p” also exists in Muslim Baghdadi Arabic, but only in loanwords, and can often be used interchangeably with “b“.

parda = “curtains” (from Persian)

pālTo= “overcoat” (from French via Persian)

pāsha= “high ranking official” (from Persian via Turkish)

Salmān Pāk= a town north of Baghdad near the Sassanid-era ruins of Ctesiphon (المدائن), named after a Persian companion of the prophet Muhammad

pūlādh= “steel” (from Mongolian via Persian)


However, some words have been irreversibly adapted to the standard Arabic sound system and have undergone the resulting sound change “p” –> “b”. Curiously enough, the resulting “b” sound is often emphatic:

toBa=”ball, cannonball” (from Turkish top)

guBBa = “room, vault” (from Persian qoppeh)